Best Italian restaurants in Key West / Florida Keys

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

7 restaurants available nearby

A photo of New York Pasta Garden restaurant

1. New York Pasta Garden

4.3

Awesome(597)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Key West

Booked 5 times today

We just had Thanksgiving dinner there last night and everyone cleared their plates!!! Had two grandkids with us who are picky and they ate so good!

A photo of La Trattoria Old Town restaurant

2. La Trattoria Old Town

4.8

Exceptional(2932)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 25 times today

Great italian food. Grateful service. Upscale ambiance.

A photo of La Trattoria Oceanside restaurant

3. La Trattoria Oceanside

4.7

Exceptional(2173)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Key West

Booked 20 times today

Our favorite Italian restaurant in the island, we are locals and we love both Trattorias but this location it’s upscale, excellent food, excellent service by Tiffany and excellent ambiance. ♥️♥️♥️

4. Antonia's

4.8

Exceptional(2130)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Key West

Booked 34 times today

Stumbled across this excellent Italian restaurant in Key West. Excited to see grilled calamari marinara on the menus. Very flavorful escargot, branzino and fettuccine bolognese.

5. Ocean Grill & Bar

4.6

Exceptional(1009)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Key West

Booked 11 times today

We had a party of seven and everyone agreed it was one of our best meals in Key West. My husband said it was the best lobster he had in a while and I really enjoyed my fettuccine Alfredo. My son-in-law had the seafood Saffron risotto and said it was excellent. Everyone else is very pleased with their dinner and we will definitely be back. Oh, their Keylime pie was excellent as well!