Best Italian Restaurants in Mercer Island

Price: Moderate (147)Price: Expensive (124)Price: Very Expensive (34)

62 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Carmine's - Bellevue restaurant

1. Carmine's - Bellevue

4.8

Exceptional(2690)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 31 times today

Carmine's - Bellevue is renowned as a top-notch Italian restaurant in Seattle, earning rave reviews for its authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant's dedicated clientele highlight the exceptional food, citing it as possibly the best on the Eastside. Diners compliment the fresh and delicious flavors in dishes like the Cioppino and Scalloppine de Vitello, which reflect the essence of traditional Italian fare. Its service is also lauded as being excellent, with professional and attentive staff. The ambiance at Carmine's is described as upscale, comfortable, and welcoming. Despite a few critiques, Carmine's is highly recommended by guests for a superb dining experience, be it a casual meal, a business dinner or a special celebration.

A photo of Cantinetta - Bellevue restaurant

2. Cantinetta - Bellevue

4.6

Exceptional(1220)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 23 times today

Situated in Bellevue, Washington, Cantinetta is a favorite among locals for its delicious Italian cuisine. The reviews show diners praising the quality of the food and the friendly, attentive service. Many reviewers have declared it their favorite Italian venue, thanks to its cozy ambiance, outstanding customer experience, and the variety of dishes on offer, including favorites like cacio e pepi, gnocchi, and risotto. Special mentions go to their cocktails and wine list. The restaurant is acclaimed for its periodic menu changes, providing an opportunity to discover a new favorite dish each visit. A wonderful neighborhood spot, Cantinetta Bellevue guarantees a delightful dining experience with authentic Italian dishes.

3. Spinasse

4.8

Exceptional(3728)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 45 times today

Spinasse is celebrated for its exquisite northern Italian cuisine. Patrons are effusive in their praise for the authenticity and quality of the dishes, from the rabbit agnolotti to the Tajarin Al Ragu, noting that the meals evoke the flavors of Italy and their own culinary heritage. Numerous customers also mention the exceptional service, knowledgeable staff, and the cozy ambiance that enhances their dining experience. The restaurant also offers a range of wonderful wines from the region. Reviewers highly recommend Spinasse, with many expressing their eagerness to return and continue their exploration of the tempting menu offerings. The fervor of the reviews underlines Spinasse's reputation as one of the best Italian restaurants in the city, if not the country.

A photo of That's Amore - Seattle restaurant

4. That's Amore - Seattle

4.7

Exceptional(1098)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Leschi / Madrona / Madison Park

Booked 5 times today

"That's Amore" is one of Seattle's finest Italian dining establishments. Renowned for its excellent authentic Italian cuisine, the restaurant consistently earns high praise from visitors as testified by their positive reviews. One customer commented on the outstanding food and service, comparing it to being just like home. The restaurant's menu showcases a variety of traditional dishes, from small plates such as "Risotto Cakes" and "Baked Goat Cheese" to larger mains like "Tuscan Pork Belly" and "Scallopini". Not to forget the vast selection of refreshing beverages including "Aperol Aperitivo" and "London Dry Big Gin". The cozy ambiance, friendly staff, and stunning city views make "That's Amore" unbeatable. The culmination of these factors not only places it in the top echelon of Italian restaurants in Seattle but also in the United States.

5. Bis on Main

4.7

Exceptional(1923)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bellevue

Booked 37 times today

Bis on Main, located in the heart of Bellevue, provides a carefully crafted blend of Northwest and French cuisine that garners high praise from its customers. Patrons commend its knowledgeable sommelier, excellent service, and the well-paced courses. Menu favorites include the NY strip, the cassoulet, the garlic fried chicken, and the seafood pasta. With a standout Caesar salad and an excellent wine list showcasing gems from the Northwest, the restaurant manages to encapsulate the essence of Northwest cuisine. The impressive wine menu is a highlight, offering extremely reasonable prices. The attention to detail, unshakeable service standards, and the quality of food make Bis on Main a prime example of great Northwest cuisine.

A photo of Il Terrazzo Carmine restaurant

6. Il Terrazzo Carmine

4.8

Exceptional(3985)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pioneer Square

Booked 48 times today

Il Terrazzo Carmine has been lauded as a destination dining spot, particularly celebrated for its authentic Italian cuisine. According to regular patrons, it is their "go-to" place in Seattle, recognized for its excellent service and noted for contributing to a great Italian dining experience. Reviewers have commended the restaurant's ambient outdoor space and welcoming atmosphere, which coupled with its finely crafted Mediterranean cuisine and classic Italian offerings, make it a highly recommended choice in the Pacific Northwest. Striking a balance between tradition and innovation, Il Terrazzo Carmine consistently receives accolades for its exceptional service, inviting ambiance, and culinary excellence making it a must-visit destination in downtown Seattle.

A photo of Tutta Bella - Columbia City restaurant

7. Tutta Bella - Columbia City

4.8

Exceptional(107)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Columbia City

Booked 5 times today

Tutta Bella in Columbia City, a Seattle neighborhood, fascinates its patrons with scrumptious Italian cuisine. The food is consistently praised for its quality - the beet salad, prosciutto appetizers, distinctive pizzas such as the pistachio with whipped ricotta and mortadella are all standout dishes. The restaurant offers a welcoming ambiance that reminds guests of a home-cooked meal. Its team effort and exceptional service have been particularly appreciated. From satisfying sophisticated Manhattanites to celebrating special occasions like a 77th birthday, Tutta Bella seems to consistently exceed expectations. Its community role as a neighborhood go-to for families has also been recognized. Whether it's their wood-fired pizzas, the other Italian dishes, or their full-service bar, there's something for everyone at this beloved spot.

8. Vendemmia

4.8

Exceptional(1098)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Leschi / Madrona / Madison Park

Booked 15 times today

Located in the heart of Seattle's Madrona neighborhood, Vendemmia stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine. Esteemed by critics and patrons alike, the restaurant is often championed for its excellent food, great Italian wine, and top-of-the-line service. It consistently receives high praise for its elegant take on traditional dishes, with reviewers often mentioning the intense level of care and sophistication poured into each dish. Its seasonal menu, featuring a creative twist on familiar Italian flavors, is often compared favorably with the offerings of the best trattorias and osterias in Italy itself. Alongside the exceptional food, Vendemmia garners acclaim for its friendly and attentive service, all while maintaining a comfortable neighborhood "feel". Whether on a casual night out or a special occasion, diners agree Vendemmia delivers an elevated dining experience.

A photo of Tutta Bella - Wallingford restaurant

9. Tutta Bella - Wallingford

4.5

Awesome(126)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Wallingford

Booked 9 times today

Tutta Bella - Wallingford comes highly recommended for its top-notch Italian cuisine, particularly its Neapolitan pizza, which is hailed as the best west of New Haven, Connecticut. This endorsement is echoed by countless patrons who commend the restaurant's consistent quality, excellent service, reasonable pricing, and well-rounded menu, full of outstanding choices. Primarily revered for their pizza, the lasagna and freshly made salads have also been lauded. The restaurant is known for its ability to cater to different dietary needs with several options, ensuring every diner enjoys a marvelous experience. The ambiance and customer service create a welcoming and friendly atmosphere, contributing to the overall positive dining experience.

10. Tulio

4.6

Exceptional(4041)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 27 times today

Tulio, a highly rated restaurant in Seattle, offers an authentic and delightful Italian culinary experience. With a variety of reviews praising its exquisite dishes and extraordinary service, it has made a grand impression on guests. Highlighted on their menu are the sweet potato gnocchi and the ahi tuna, which have received high praise and been deemed as 'excellent'. The romantic ambiance and professionalism of the staff further enhance the dining experience. Many reviewers underscored the excellent Italian wines on the wine list, and appreciate the availability of dishes which cater to a broad age range. In essence, Tulio provides a remarkable Italian dining experience, emphasising traditional flavours with a contemporary twist.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Mercer Island

Italian