13 Best Pizzerias In Fisher Island

13 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Il Pizzaiolo - Neapolitan Pizzeria restaurant

1. Il Pizzaiolo - Neapolitan Pizzeria

4.7

Exceptional(67)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 3 times today

The food and service were top notch, highly recommend, pizza is the best I’ve had, meatballs were excellent,Cesar salad was done right! Good wine selection

A photo of Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach restaurant

2. Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

4.5

Awesome(396)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 15 times today

Our favorite Italian restaurant in South Beach. Beautiful interior and friendly staff make you feel welcome. The cacio e pepe is a feast of delicious proportions! We paired with a nice wine at a very reasonable price. Juan, our server made our night perfect. See you again on our next visit!

A photo of BELLILLO US - Pizzeria Napoletana restaurant

3. BELLILLO US - Pizzeria Napoletana

4.6

Exceptional(82)

££££

• Pizzeria • Brickell

Booked 6 times today

I found this gem while searching for the best pizza in the area, and it completely blew me away. As someone who travels extensively around the world and considers myself a bit of a pizza connoisseur, I can confidently say that Bellillo has secured a solid top-three spot on my global list of all-time best pizzas. We started with the Polpetta appetizer, and the meat was incredibly tender, moist, and packed with flavor. For the main course, I went with the Nazionale pizza and added truffle—a brilliant off-menu modification recommended by the staff (Linda). The crust, char, and toppings were absolutely world-class. The service here truly elevates the entire meal. I shared my personal wine preferences with the team, and they curated a flawless pairing that complemented the food perfectly. To top it all off, they suggested trying the Tiramisu Al Pistacchio for dessert, and all I can say is—WOW! The welcoming, attentive, and highly knowledgeable staff completely enhanced the entire evening. Massive credit goes to Linda for making this such a successful, memorable, and enjoyable experience. Thank you, Bellillo Restaurant and Linda ! I will definitely be back.

A photo of Fratelli La Bufala restaurant

4. Fratelli La Bufala

4.4

Awesome(713)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 5 times today

The pizza 🍕 tastes just like in Napoli … delicious !! The spaghetti , also great ! Our server , Dylan, took amazing care of us!!!

5. Casa Amore

4.4

Awesome(29)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

I think the staff did a nice job. They were pleasant, They allowed us to split some chicken parm at no extra charge. The chicken parm was very fresh,, and they didn’t use some pre over fried chicken patty! The fettuccine Alfredo was delicious

A photo of Il Bolognese Italian Restaurant Miami Beach restaurant

6. Il Bolognese Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

3.9

Excellent(87)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 4 times today

Great restaurant great vibe great pasta, we got the truffle gnocchi and the angus beef pasta it was delicious

A photo of Di Mauro's Italian Restaurant & Bar restaurant

7. Di Mauro's Italian Restaurant & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(347)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 5 times today

up there with the top 3 italian restaurants ive been too, staff are very friendly, the meatballs and tiramisu are unreal

A photo of 'O Munaciello MiMo District restaurant

8. 'O Munaciello MiMo District

4.7

Exceptional(208)

££££

• Pizzeria • MiMo / Upper East Side

Booked 10 times today

Yummy pizzas. Very good quality of meal. Good prices

A photo of Pizza Tua Italian Restaurant restaurant

9. Pizza Tua Italian Restaurant

4.1

Excellent(32)

££££

• Pizzeria • South Beach

Booked 1 time today

Excellent real Italian Pizza, service top notch, we also had Caesar Salad which was one of the best I have ever had. Tiramisu was a great addition to a very good meal

10. Battubelin Miami

4.8

Exceptional(473)

££££

• Pizzeria • MiMo / Upper East Side

Booked 10 times today

Wonderful restaurant and great place to meet friends for lunch and dinner. Italian with a Miami vibe and very cool 😎

Best Pizzerias in Fisher Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Il Pizzaiolo - Neapolitan Pizzeria

2. Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

3. BELLILLO US - Pizzeria Napoletana

4. Fratelli La Bufala

5. Casa Amore

6. Il Bolognese Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

7. Di Mauro's Italian Restaurant & Bar

8. 'O Munaciello MiMo District

9. Pizza Tua Italian Restaurant

10. Battubelin Miami

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable