Best Pre-Theater Restaurants in Southold

My husband and I like to celebrate our anniversary at Pasta Pasta. This year being our 30th we were very excited to go. From the time we checked in and wished a Happy Anniversary and offered 2 glasses of complimentary champagne to the very end everything was amazing. Our server was Andrew M and he was an absolute delight. He offered suggestions and checked on us throughout our meal. We had the Monday Night Dinner for Two and for the price, it was a lot of food. Everything was delicious. We had a wonderful time celebrating our special anniversary at Pasta Pasta.

Food was fantastic, server was friendly, will definitely be back

The space was classy (love the decor) and the high backed booths made conversation easy even thought the restaurant was full. The food was delicious and our server Jake was very attentive and fun.

Our favorite restaurant. Last night we had oysters on the half shell with a fabulous vinaigrette. We shared a Shrimp and Clam handpie that was out of this world. I had the Roasted Monkfish and my husband had the Prime strip. For dessert was the Sugar Pumpkin Creme Brulé. Once again, Chef Taylor waved his magic wand and provided dishes that continue to leave beautiful memories. Our main server Peter, and Renee were great with every attention to detail. Every single meal there has been an adventure leaving us begging for more.

Enjoyed good food and service at Whiskey Neat. Menu was varied with something for everyone. Service/wait person was friendly and accommodating. Overall great experience pre-theater especially for a busy Saturday evening. A return visit definitely in the future.