Best Restaurants for Foodies in East Setauket

After quite a few breakfasts and lunches over the years, I finally tried out the dinner menu and what a winner! We took friends out to celebrate a birthday enjoyed a truly perfect evening. The food and drinks were fantastic, the service was warm and attentive, and the ambiance can’t be beat. We can’t wait to go back!

This restaurant is the most consistent restaurant I’ve ever been to! The wait service is phenomenal! From Erin to Sean, to bus service by Luis and entrees delivered by Kevin, it is #1 on my favorite restaurant list! Management is doing everything right here! Management also makes themselves present and I believe this sets them apart from other restaurants! The food is always cooked perfectly and it’s consistently delicious and fresh! I rant and rave about Insignia because I’ve yet to find any restaurant that beats it! I can always count on a delicious, well served meal when dining out at Insignia! Thank you for this gem!!

Our service was excellent, and we extend our appreciation to our waiter.

Perfection from start to finish—10/10! We celebrated our anniversary here this week, and the experience couldn't have been more exceptional. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and refined. Every single course was standard-setting—the appetizers, the main entrees, and a truly unforgettable dessert were all executed to absolute perfection. It’s rare for a restaurant to hit top marks on every single element, but this evening was a true 10 out of 10. Thank you to the entire staff for making our anniversary so special. We will definitely be back!

It was a wonderful way to celebrate Valentine's Day. Over the top festuve