Best Fireplace restaurants in Shelter Island

February 2020
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
Sun
27
28
29
30
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
21:00
2 people
Price
Cuisines(20 of 77)

307 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Vine Street Cafe restaurant
1. Vine Street Cafe
4.8
Exceptional(1017)
  • $$$$
  • American
  • Shelter Island
Booked 2 times today

This was the perfect spot for a winter's eve with the welcoming, cozy atmosphere. Servers were excellent and knowledgeable. Many fine choices on the menu. I had the miso salmon which was fabulous - and I often order salmon but this was a stand out preparation. Really good wine, great desserts. No...

A photo of Noah's restaurant
2. Noah's
4.5
Awesome(1512)
  • $$$$
  • Tapas / Small Plates
  • Greenport
Booked 1 time today

Noah’s was an excellent choice for Valentines dinner. The 5 course menu was outstanding, as well as my peach jalapeño cocktail . Service and atmosphere is always great!

A photo of Ellen's on Front restaurant
3. Ellen's on Front
4.8
Exceptional(1)
  • $$$$
  • American
  • Greenport

The food was delicious and portions great for sharing. The wait staff were very enthusiastic and nice.

A photo of Olive Branch Cafe restaurant
4. Olive Branch Cafe
4.5
Awesome(64)
  • $$$$
  • Turkish
  • Greenport
Booked 1 time today

Like the best home cooked meal you’ve ever had. Authentic and delicious.

A photo of The Halyard restaurant
5. The Halyard
4.5
Awesome(469)
  • $$$$
  • American
  • Greenport
Booked 2 times today

The atmosphere is relaxed and upscale. There are wonderful views from every seat in the establishment that will keep you coming back. My wife order the fish and chips and I ordered the swordfish over creamy polenta. My meal was fantastic but my wife’s fish was greasy, flavorless and the...

A photo of M.J. Dowling's restaurant
6. M.J. Dowling's
4.7
Exceptional(57)
  • $$$$
  • American
  • Sag Harbor

Too much food. Took home enough of our meal to have another dinner the next day,

A photo of K Pasa restaurant
7. K Pasa
4.3
Awesome(12)
  • $$$$
  • Tapas / Small Plates
  • Sag Harbor

Portion small otherwise delicious

A photo of Baron's Cove restaurant
8. Baron's Cove
4.4
Awesome(422)
  • $$$$
  • American
  • Sag Harbor
Booked 3 times today

Always a lovely atmosphere on a cold winter night with the fireplace blazing. Food is consistently good as well as the service

A photo of Tutto Il Giorno - Sag Harbor restaurant
9. Tutto Il Giorno - Sag Harbor
4.7
Exceptional(114)
  • $$$$
  • Italian
  • Sag Harbor
Booked 2 times today

Perfect in every way. The octopus was amazing. I’ve had the spaghetti before. It’s always amazing. Our server was the high point. Very attentive, efficient and friendly.

A photo of The American Hotel restaurant
10. The American Hotel
4.8
Exceptional(159)
  • $$$$
  • French
  • Sag Harbor
Booked 3 times today

We have been to coming to The American Hotel for many years and always enjoy a lovely dinner here.