Best Restaurants for Special Occasions in 39th St / Westport / Midtown

My husband and I celebrated our 30th anniversary at Stock Hill. For a Monday evening, it was surprisingly busy in the main dining area. We were quickly seated, extra place settings removed, and waters poured. Our server, Anna, was amazing and allowed us to take our time and enjoy the experience. We ordered several cocktails, though the Rocking Chair and the Wolf of Main Street were easily our favorites! The Wagyu meatballs are a MUST! Absolutely delicious. We also shared a wedge salad, which was fresh and had a nice amount of toppings. We chose the Tomahawk for Two with the carmelized onion and chive butter, sides of fondue whipped yukons and mac drop, and an extra side of asparagus. The tomahawk steak came out already sliced, which slightly disappointed my husband. He wanted the experience of seeing it whole. However, the flavor was really great, especially with the butter. It was well seasoned and had a nice char on bits. All the sides were delicious and my non-veggie-loving husband favored the asparagus in its delicious butter sauce. We ordered the bread pudding dessert, and it was completely divine! From food to service and attentiveness, everyone at Stock Hill made our 30th anniversary such a special occasion. 10/10 would recommend!

Great meal, as always. Delicious and excellent service.

We’ve never had a bad experience at Pierpont’s and yesterday brunch was no different. Good friends, great meal, terrific service and the best atmosphere. Thanks.

Our server was impeccable in every way to give us the first class service we expected. All of our food was exceptionally good as it always is every time. You will never be disappointed at J Gilbert’s.

Excellent meal and service in cozy atmosphere. Will dine again!