30 Best Historic Restaurants in Fire Island

30 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Shands General & The State Room restaurant

1. Shands General & The State Room

4.6

Exceptional(432)

££££

• American • Patchogue

Booked 27 times today

Another Home run by Augusta Distillery and Shands General. Whiskey & Food Pairing Perfection!!!!! At The State Room!!!!!!

A photo of Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi restaurant

2. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi

4.8

Exceptional(7548)

££££

• Steakhouse • Smithtown

Booked 76 times today

Andres was a great server. The food and the experience was an excellent way to celebrate our anniversary.

A photo of Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue restaurant

3. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

4.7

Exceptional(455)

££££

• Mexican • Patchogue

Booked 2 times today

Ruta Oaxaca is a favorite of ours and is in the regular rotation of our take-me- out Tuesday friends group. We enjoy the warm welcome, professional service and delicious food!

4. Hendrick's Tavern

4.7

Exceptional(2935)

££££

• American • Roslyn

Booked 72 times today

Quality food and quality service. Would definitely recommend.

A photo of OHK Bar & Restaurant restaurant

5. OHK Bar & Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(3675)

££££

• American • Huntington

Booked 26 times today

Oheka Castle is a magical place with beautiful grounds and history. The food was exceptional with equally terrific service.

6. The Garden Grill

3.7

Very Good(108)

££££

• American • Smithtown

Booked 8 times today

Celebrated a birthday dinner here. We chose to sit in a quiet area, though there was music near the bar. Our server, Kelly, was very attentive but never overbearing. The Prix Fixe Menu had great selections. The seafood bisque, short ribs, and beignets were delish! It was a lovely dining experience.

A photo of Mirabelle Restaurant and Tavern at the Three Village Inn restaurant

7. Mirabelle Restaurant and Tavern at the Three Village Inn

4.0

Excellent(1492)

££££

• Contemporary American • Stony Brook

Booked 18 times today

Food was absolutely wonderful! Restaurant was surprisingly full. Had a wonderful time with my friends

A photo of Porters on the Lane restaurant

8. Porters on the Lane

4.6

Exceptional(981)

££££

• American • Bellport

Booked 9 times today

Always a solid place to eat. Consistently good food and atmosphere is warm. Never feel rushed through dinner so it’s a good place to gather with friends to catch up.

9. Sandbar

4.6

Exceptional(2178)

££££

• American • Cold Spring Harbor

Booked 30 times today

Always happy here. The chick pea “fries” are mandatory!!!

10. Pasta Pasta

4.7

Exceptional(2233)

££££

• Contemporary Italian • Port Jefferson

Booked 12 times today

My husband and I like to celebrate our anniversary at Pasta Pasta. This year being our 30th we were very excited to go. From the time we checked in and wished a Happy Anniversary and offered 2 glasses of complimentary champagne to the very end everything was amazing. Our server was Andrew M and he was an absolute delight. He offered suggestions and checked on us throughout our meal. We had the Monday Night Dinner for Two and for the price, it was a lot of food. Everything was delicious. We had a wonderful time celebrating our special anniversary at Pasta Pasta.

Best Historic Restaurants in Fire Island

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

30 restaurants available nearby

1. Shands General & The State Room

2. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi

3. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

4. Hendrick's Tavern

5. OHK Bar & Restaurant

6. The Garden Grill

7. Mirabelle Restaurant and Tavern at the Three Village Inn

8. Porters on the Lane

9. Sandbar

10. Pasta Pasta

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable