Gilbey's Old Amersham
Having successfully created the first Gilbey’s in Eton in 1975, we acquired what was then the celebrated old tea shop (The Willow Tree) in 1989. After extensive alterations on the history-steeped listed building, Gilbey’s was established, boasting a stylish yet intimate restaurant, a stunning first-floor private dining room and an attractive garden.
Our team is dedicated to delivering the very best quality and value to our customers and assure you of a very warm welcome at Gilbey’s Old Amersham.
Consistently good - faultless.
The food tried to be clever but the main taste was lost in the juices, the chef seemed too fond of beetroot
We have been eating at Gilbeys’s for more than 30 years, it has never let us down. The service and food excellent. This time we had a baby with us and the staff couldn’t have been more helpful at seating us somewhere with a pushchair and providing hot water for milk etc. We look forward to many more lovely meals here.
Our lunch was as I hoped it would be, so glad I chose Gilbey’s to treat my friend for her 50th Birthday lunch. Thank you
For 15 years, although we visit infrequently, this remains our favourite restaurant.
Would definitely recommend and will be going back. Superb food! Efficient, friendly and helpful staff.
Wanted a comfortable lunch to celebrate our 25th anniversary. Gilbey’s hit the right tone with attentive but unobtrusive service and a great value, but very lovely lunch menu
Excellent Sunday lunch. Great food.
We were put into a rather cramped alcove with another table as there was a large party taking over the main dining room. We were so close to them that we could hardly hear each other as the noise level was extremely high. The couple on the other table left after their main course as they had had enough of the noise. The food was excellent, but did rather marr our experience. It is a fairly small restaurant.
Very good food and service. Well placed in Old Amersham
Gilbeys is long established and we have eaten there for years. Sadly in recent years the menu has become tired. Some dishes have been included year on year without variation. This visit the sirloin steak was awful, tough and presentation of the plate was poor. Garnish comprised small bunch of watercress, one escallion and the best bit was 6 hand cooked chips - all for £30.00! the glass of red wine was given free as compensation, good but not really adequate in relation to the price of the steak.
Soup was hot, but plate for other main only warm not hot.
Very sad as the ambience is good. This is not the first time we have been disappointed reently an now we shall not return.
Nice food with good service.......at a fair price
Great as always!
Lovely as always.
Had a 2 course set dinner menu - fabulous and right size portions.
Great service as usual
Small restaurant with a lovely atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff. The restaurant has been in Amersham for many years and all the meals we have had there have been most enjoyable. Always busy and buzzing. We both had the sea bream for our main course - good sized portions and beautifully cooked and presented.
I have been frequenting Gilbey’s for at least the last ten years. For any occasion or just an indulgent lunch, the food is delicious, service great, nothing is too much trouble, even if you have difficult dietary requirements they are always willing to provide you with a satisfying and delicious meal. The menu is varied seasonally with fresh ingredients and some new which are excellent, you will never be bored at Gilbey’s
Friendly atmosphere, took my Mum and Sister for a light lunch. Perfect for our needs.
My colleagues and I have been visiting this restaurant for over 15 years and it never ceases to disappoint. Staff are very friendly but professional and the food is gorgeous as always.
I would have liked to see more options on the menu for those who don't eat dairy. It was a very traditional menu. The service was very slow. But the food we ate was nice and well cooked and as the waitress advised the sorbets were very good. There was no acknowledgement of the fact I had stated it was a birthday and an anniversary on the booking form. Elsewhere for a friend's birthday we were greeted with complimentary bubbly and a pudding. Not as excellent as I had anticipated.
Nice for a treat, however expensive for food that wasn't quite right the whole time, steak was slightly overdone and duck was a bit too salty
Went there for wedding anniversary and they put us into a nice private area off the main dining room (I had not told them of the anniversary, but perhaps because we were dressed up we got this particular table) - food, wine and service all very good.
Food was excellent staff were brilliant went that little extra when they found out I was taking my daughter for her birthday lunch thank you.
Superb, as always. Set lunch menu is always excellent. Very good on gluten free options too
We've been going to Gilbey's in Old Amersham for over 10 years now, once or twice a year for anniversaries or birthdays, and we've never been disappointed. Consistently good quality and value, served by a team who care about your dining experience.
We had a lovely meal, the food was delicious. We will be back.
I have visited Gilbey's many times and been delighted with my meal but last Friday I was not.
I started with the rice ball which was tasteless. I followed with Plaice supposedly served with pickled vegetables and potatoes.
The vegetables were definitely not pickled and the beans were burnt black to an extent that I could not believe that any self respecting chef could plate them up and serve them. They took them back and then when the plate came back the beans were very very undercooked.
I will return as I feel that it was a one off, but Gilbey's really need to be more careful, they are not cheap and such occurrences should not happen.
Very attentive staff.
Meal perfect, took my 83 year old Mum, staff were lovely. Good choice of wines. Would recommend.
Our 4th time here and 1st for Sunday lunch which was delicious. It’s a pleasure to come here it’s a charming with a lovely ambience and even better delicious food.
Romantic meal for two, so hoping the restaurant would not be too busy. It wasn’t, but this does not reflect on our experiences which was excellent. Friendly, prompt, attentive but not intrusive service. Quality of food ( 1 starter, 2 mains, 1 dessert) was outstanding, the stand out being the Bakewell tart, which we fought over,
Only very minor quibble, was the waitress sitting us in an end booth with two 2 person tables next to another couple, when the rest of the restaurant was only half full. Having another couple enjoying an intimate dinner à deux right next to you in a private space would have been a little weird. We were however promptly moved to another table, with no fuss.
Overall an excellent experience. Will be back.
Having not eaten at Gilbey's for 20 years, I was pleasantly surprised by the menu and food we ate for lunch. Delicious and tasty, fresh and priced accordingly.
The resturant was very busy for a Wednesday lunchtime, what's also good to see is a resturant that keeps its decor and bathrooms up to standard.
I will most certainly be returning before the next 20 years whizz by.
Great restaurant with excellent choice and great value.
We had an excellent dinner, celebrating my wife's birthday. Each course was delicious, the atmosphere was relaxing and the staff were friendly and attentive without being intrusive. Altogether, a really positive experience.
This is a lovely restaurant and the food was really good if a little pricey but worth it. I had read that service was slow but would say the opposite a little rushed but we asked for extra time to make our minds up. Will definitely return
Lovely old building but very bland disappointing food. They also knew it was a birthday dinner & nothing was mentioned throughout.
Asked for medium rare steak and a medium rare lamb. The lamb was laughingly small and I was offered another piece. But both steak and lamb were well done. No excuse at 7.30 and only six other diners. We then had to wait for new meals to be cooked.
Our main courses were not charged after I complained when paying the bill but our wedding anniversary was effectively ruined. This is the second time in a row that medium rare was over cooked. We will not go again.
Whilst the food and service were very good it did feel that we were trapped in an early ‘90’s time warp, there were very few customers for a Thursday evening, this didn’t help much either.
We had a perfect anniversary evening drinking lovely wine and eating delicious food, with perfect service in a beautiful old building.
A perfect place to spend our wedding anniversary... excellent friendly and attentive service, perfect good and betty very good wines. Thanks