Restaurants near Cotuit Anchorage

We had an early reservation on a Saturday night, so the restaurant was fairly empty and therefore quite quiet. It was beginning to fill up by the time we left at 6:30 but still was not at all noisy. The venue is an old inn and was very nicely decorated. At the entry hall is a display case filled with old nutcrackers which was fun to view while we waited a few minutes for the hostess. The food was excellent, and we first enjoyed the fried calamari which was among the best we have had. The bread served was very fresh and delicious and served very warm with an accompanying olive oil with garlic pieces and peppers that was a special enhancement. Our main meals were the pancetta scallop dish and the chicken piccata, both generous portions with excellent pasta accompaniments. We also enjoyed the Limoncello cake with vanilla gelato for dessert. No part of the meal was a disappointment. The service was also first rate, and we appreciated that our server checked with us on a few occasions to see if we needed anything. I wish more waitstaff were as efficient. We will definitely be returning sometime in the summer when we are back on the Cape.

Tourists, first and only visit here. Fabulous steaks, truly delicious. Our waitress, Bella, was outstanding. It’s very expensive but as long as you’re prepared for that you won’t be disappointed. Very glad we tried it.

Excellent! Great service, creative and delicious dinners

Very enjoyable meal. All food hot, presentable and service great. Can’t wait to return

We were a party of 5 and were quickly greeted and sat at a beautiful table overlooking the water Our serving team was attentive and thoughtful. Meals came out exactly as we requested. Awesome night with friends , awesome night at Popponesset Inn!!!!