Bay Shore Restaurants

Updated on 05/11/2026

Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.

Magnolias - New York

Diners’ top pick

•

$$$$

•

Tapas / Small Plates

•

4.9

(62)

We only reserve a small number of tables each night, if your preferred time isn’t listed, we’d still love to have you stop by! Walk-ins are always welcome.
Magnolias is a cocktail bar that brings timeless cocktail culture to Bay Shore. Known for impeccable martinis, elevated small plates, and hospitality that makes every guest feel like a regular. Our menu features timeless cocktails crafted with precision, spirit-forward creations, and a fresh raw bar designed for sharing. The atmosphere is upscale but approachable—perfect for after-work drinks, date nights, or lingering with friends. Located in the heart of Bay Shore, Magnolias is a community gathering spot where classic cocktail culture meets modern hospitality. Join us for martinis, oysters, and an evening that feels effortlessly refined.

Find next available

---

1. 

   Mamma Santina Italian Restaurant

   $$$$

   •

   Italian

   •

   4.8

   (15)

   Mamma Santina has been a staple in the Brightwaters community since 1988. You will find a brightly lit casual atmosphere with a full bar, wood-fired brick oven and a huge outdoor seating space. With the Fire Island ferries just a few minutes away, it's the perfect spot to grab a slice of pizza or have a comfortable sit-down dinner with your family. The menu has something for everyone including, wood-fired brick oven pizza, wild caught Shrimp Oreganata, or their signature Penne alla Vodka.
2. 

   KISEKI Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

   $$$$

   •

   Japanese (Hibachi)

   •

   4.8

   (172)

   This advanced version of sushi & hibachi all you can eat offers a unique dining experience that combines traditional sushi with table hibachi grilling. Customers can choose from a variety of fresh sushi appetizer, sushi, sushi roll, sushi special roll and kitchen teriyaki, tempura other Japanese dishes in the all you can eat, then enjoy the interactive cooking process on the table hibachi grill, skillfully performed by professional chefs.
   This dining concept seamlessly blends traditional sushi culture with modern cooking techniques, providing customers with a diverse range of flavorful options. The interactive and engaging nature of this dining experience, coupled with the assurance of fresh and high-quality ingredients, sets it apart.

Salt and Barrel

Top-rated food

•

$$$$

•

Contemporary American

•

4.7

(1,877)

An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe and vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps, and coastal fare with a rotating selection of east/west coast oysters daily.

Find next available

---

1. 

   The Lakehouse

   $$$$

   •

   Contemporary American

   •

   4.7

   (3,590)

   Since 2006, The LakeHouse restaurant has been the jewel of Bay Shore, NY. In the summer of 2016, owners Eileen & Matthew Connors and Jay Gut moved locations to a brand new dockside treasure. With stunning views and multiple fireplaces, comfortable seating for 100+ guests, two lounge areas, deck overlooking the Great South Bay, and both an indoor tavern room and a waterfront bar, The Lakehouse is touted by many as “one of the best restaurants on Long Island.” At night, the deck is illuminated, as is the waterfront lounge area where guests can congregate for after-dinner cocktails. This New American fine dining experience is not to be missed. The Lakehouse can now be reached by boat as well, as guest dockage is available at the new gorgeous bayside locale.
   *Please note that we not take reservations for particular tables & we cannot promise a particular area or table.
2. 

   Captain Bill's

   $$$$

   •

   Seafood

   •

   4.6

   (2,336)

   Treat those you love to casual, yet elegant waterfront dining on the Great South Bay at Captain Bill's, where you can savor the spectacular sunset over the water while enjoying a fresh daily selection of clams, oysters and fresh local fish along with live Maine lobsters from our lobster tank. We also specialize in premium aged steaks and prime rib, prepared just the way you like it.
   If you are looking for a lighter bite, join us in our bar where we offer a menu featuring baby lamb chops, shrimp quesadillas and the best burger in town. Wind down the work week on Friday's happy hour with discounted house drinks, domestic beer and wine(Happy Hour Mon-Fri, 4-7). Every Sunday, Captain Bill's presents one of Long Islands premier brunch buffets. Featuring unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas and Champagne as well as an extensive buffet. Bring your friends and family for a wonderful Sunday Brunch by the harbor.
   (Deck and Window tables will be accommodated on a first come first serve basis)

Whalers

Top-rated hospitality

•

$$$$

•

Contemporary American

•

4.6

(1,523)

We’re so excited to bring Whalers to Bay Shore and share our love of amazing food and great drinks with the community. Our menu is modern American cuisine, so you’ll find the classics that you’re used to but with our own little spin. In addition to our casual dining and nightlife, we also offer full catering services. With huge windows and views of the Great South Bay, Whalers will be the perfect location to host your next event!
We will do our best to accommodate your requests, but we cannot guarantee where you will be seated. Additionally, reservations are unavailable for dockside dining, as outdoor tables are first come first serve.
Whalers is modern and fresh with a nod to what it’s like growing up on the Great South Bay. Located right in the middle of the action down on Maple Ave, we are looking forward to getting customers who live locally, but also those who are heading over to Fire Island.
We look forward to serving you!

Find next available

---

1. 

   Bar Lucy

   $$$$

   •

   Contemporary Italian

   •

   4.7

   (1,067)

   Bar Lucy is Bay Shore’s newest and sexiest Italian Restaurant featuring Quality Fare, Thoughtfully Crafted Cocktails, Beer, & Wine in a visually stunning yet comfortable environment! Join us for an Aperol Spritz, Cavatelli Bolognese or a Personal Pizza to Start, End or Enhance your day with us either in House or for Take-Out.
   
2. 

   Bella Vie

   $$$$

   •

   Italian

   •

   4.5

   (609)

   An Award Winning Romantic Italian French waterfront restaurant nestled in the heart of Bay Shore.

Bella Mia Cafe - Restaurant

Great vibe

•

$$$$

•

Italian

•

4.5

(9)

Bella Mia Cafe, a delightful addition to Bay Shore's bustling Main Street, offers a warm invitation to experience authentic Italian-style cuisine. Dedicated to bringing the vibrant flavors of Italy to the community, this charming cafe emphasizes fresh, quality ingredients in every creation. Guests can start their day with a delightful breakfast, enjoy satisfying midday options like handcrafted sandwiches and specialty flatbreads, or gather for an evening of exquisite desserts and beverages. Bella Mia Cafe aims to provide a welcoming atmosphere where patrons can savor thoughtfully prepared food, offering a refreshing and wholesome alternative for any meal. It's a perfect spot for a casual bite or a relaxed after-dinner treat in the heart of the neighborhood.

Find next available

---

1. 

   Nicky's on the Bay

   $$$$

   •

   Seafood

   •

   4.3

   (231)

   Welcome to Nicky’s on the Bay — a top-rated waterfront restaurant in Bay Shore, NY, known for fresh seafood, handcrafted cocktails, and stunning views of the Great South Bay. For over a decade, we’ve been Long Island’s go-to seasonal destination for dockside dining and unforgettable sunsets. Whether you arrive by car or pull up by boat, you're always welcome at Nicky’s — where every seat comes with a view.