1. Jonathan's Restaurant - New Hyde Park4.7Exceptional(812)$$$$AmericanNew Hyde ParkBooked 7 times todayJonathan’s appreciates my patronage. I requested a quiet table for a get-together and was seated in a very nice location. Service was pleasant. I come here regularly.2. Luigi's Restaurant & Bar4.6Exceptional(866)$$$$ItalianNew Hyde ParkBooked 24 times todayExcellent but the noise level was a little overpowering.3. Umberto's of New Hyde Park - Original4.6Exceptional(375)$$$$ItalianNew Hyde ParkBooked 4 times todayUmbertos is my family’s favorite Italian restaurant, We have eaten several entrees from the dinner menu and all have been delicious 😋4. Oscar's Restaurant4.4Awesome(12)$$$$ItalianNew Hyde ParkPolished, welcoming staff. Willing to accommodate dietary restrictions by modifying preparation of my fish. The spiced bass was in beyond delicious!!