Delmonicos Italian Steak House
We also serve homemade Italian specialties, including pasta, seafood dishes, bruschetta, garlic bread, salads, chicken dishes, and cannoli, as well as a great selection of wines.
Our server was great.
Great place for italian food and friendly service.
Amazing food and atmosphere.
Overall it was a great experience. Our waiter was great and food was excellent!
Best Cannoli ever!
The food was great, our server was attentive but our apps were not ordered so entrees came out after a stretch of time. They were attentive about mistake and comped dessert, it was just a disappointment because it sounded great and we were looking forward to it.
We had a 6:30 reservation and waited over 30 minutes at the bar for our table. They should have bought our drink at the bar for having to wait so long. Then, there was a hair in one someone’s side dish at our table. They took the side dish off the bill and offered us a free dessert because of it. Manager came and apologized. I like it there, but they need a little more polishing. Our server was good but not exceptional.
We love coming here and it’s the go-to place we bring my parents to every year for their anniversary.
My dad always gets the chicken Sinatra and my husband usually gets the filet Sinatra (not on the menu but it used to be and you can still order it if you ask) but they were out of filet for this dish so he chose the eggplant/chicken parm special which was also wonderful. I love their wedge salad and got the filet mignon. My mom always gets the delmonico. We will be back!
It was our 23rd anniversary, I got the sliced strip steak and let me tell you that was THE BEST meat I have ever had in my life! Amazing. We were too full for desert but we will be back! Thank You!
Best steaks are here. You don’t need a special occasion to enjoy yourself. Bring a friend, they will be so happy
Very overpriced. Limited menu options. (For example, why offer eggplant parm only in combowith chicken parm? But you offer veal parm as a single choice.
Steak choices very limited. Mediocre seasoning. No traditional side salad offered only :entree size with meat.
Good service, food was very good and prepared as ordered.
The food is very good but the only problem is that they have an up-charge when you change the pasta to a potato when you order a steak. I know it's an Italian Steakhouse. So maybe that's why it normally comes with a side of pasta but I normally like a potato side. Other than that everything was great. It is definitely a nice place to have a relaxing dinner. Service was great, they were attentive but did not hover. They knew when we needed something and were there but also let us be able to talk at dinner without interrupting us.
The atmosphere has that Italian flavor from the Soprano's to the Sinatra room decorating the walls and Dean Martin singing while eating.
We were seated next to a very large and rowdy group. The magician did not help the noise level. Service was extremely slow. Food was luke warm, martini warm, salmon overcooked... We ended up spending $50 a person for a lousy evening!
Generally we enjoy Delmonico’s very much. Tonight was slower than normal and I think that resulted in spotty service overall. The waitress was friendly and welcoming, but once our order was placed she seemed to be almost non present. Our dinners arrived just a few minutes after our salads which resulted in our steak and pasta being lukewarm by the time we finished our salads. Would have sent my steak back for a few more minutes in the broiler to reheat but our waitress was nowhere to be found. By the time she re-visited, it wasn’t worth the wait. She did briefly acknowledge that our entrees arrived to quickly but did not offer any solution.
We will return, but hope that they are more attentive to details regardless of the level of business in the restaurant.
It all comes down to the service and presentation. It was bad... No Bread, No plates for the hors d'oeuvres and the steak was sitting all by itself on a white plate. No garnishing. Then I asked for a cup of coffee and only got the bill.
The place was not busy so our waitress was standing around talking with her friends.
This was our first visit back to Delmonicos in years, and we were happily surprised that nothing has changed. Food. Service. Value. Cleanliness. All great! We'll be back sooner rather than later!
Unfortunately this visit was not up to par. Our appetizers came out COLD - not lukewarm. They were comped but would have rather paid and have them hot. Meals came out lukewarm at best and the rare-med steak came out medium well. Baked potatoes were gone and we had 5:30 reservations - how can you run out of baked potatoes so early? I don't base the restaurant on this experience. Our past experience was very good - that's why we pretty much ordered the same items for this party. The waiter was excellent as was the manager. Told them we did not want anything free but they still comped the apps. Overall food was fair this visit but will give it another try before not returning.
This was the third time we have been here, and have enjoyed it every time. the food is good, and reasonably priced, and we both walked away with leftovers.
The service was good but the food was so-so. Seemed overpriced for ok food.
Excellent service and excellent food, great atmosphere and very reasonable prices.
The food was great and the service was wonderful as well.
The food at Delmonico's is very expensive. However, the process does not meet the expectations for food. My vegetables were undercooked, as were my mother's. The chicken was not well seasoned, and it was eight dollars for four extra shrimp. Definitely will not be going back there.
The taste of the food was different, not good, but different. My steak was ordered well done and came medium to medium rare. The waitress did not come to check on us so there was no opportunity for them to cook the steak as ordered before my husband was done with his food. The sauce was loaded with onions, which I don’t eat, and the description of the entree did not list onions or else I would not have ordered it. My husband ran out of drink and waitress did not bring refill but managed to charge us for extra beer that he did not receive. The service was horrible. If the waitress had done her job, this review would have more than likely been much better for the restaurant. I ended up eating chips for dinner because nothing else was open when we left the restaurant. Very disappointing experience.
Great we have been to Delmonico's before and always had a wonderful meal and time service is great and always we will be back
Everyone should go to Delmonicos at least once. The one I visited was below average.
Great place to eat a big steak with your friends. The menu had a pretty wide variety of offerings without being totally overwhelming. Sound levels were just right and you could easily carry on conversations without feeling like you had to raise your voice to be heard.
It was my first time at Delmonicos and I love it! We celebrated our anniversary and they made it a memorable one. Best Italian restaurant in Rochester.
Great steakhouse! We like going here with the family as the variety is great and the food is very good.
Great service. Great food. Very nice facility. Had a great time.
We met relatives from out of town for an evening get-together. We were able to spend our time in a very relaxed atmosphere where we were not rushed and we were able to spend quality time with our family. We were very happy.
Everything was great!
Everything was great, there was a large party right next to us. we asked to move away from them, and they moved us right away! Thank you for a great night!
Good food and good value. We were in Rochester area for 3 days and went to Dellmonicos twice.
Our appetizer was undercooked and not tasty. One of the meals (tenderloin tips) was tough and not edible. All in all the meal was overpriced.
Celebrating anniversary was great setup table with flowers that I purchased
Family had a fun time, good service and good food ! Def recommend it !!!
Delicious meal! Great service. We will look forward to returning and trying additional menu items.
Good food as usual, overall a good time!
Great waiter, excellent service and delicious food with wonderful presentation.
We were celebrating our anniversary with my sister in law. My wife had a chicken w/pasta dish which was tasty. My sister in law had chicken Sinatra which was also very good. I had the 1 and 1/2 Delmonico. After working in the meat industry I understand that rib steaks tend to be fattier than strips, porters, sirloins etc. But my steak had between 8 and 10 ozs. of fat, This has never happened in the appx. 20 X we have dined there. You asked for feed back and here it is.