Delmonicos Italian Steak House
We also serve homemade Italian specialties, including pasta, seafood dishes, bruschetta, garlic bread, salads, chicken dishes, and cannoli, as well as a great selection of wines.
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Delmonico's Delmonico Steak
-1/2 Pound (HUGE 24 oz) Certified Angus Beef, Center Cut Rib-eye Steak from Midwestern Grain Fed Heavy Aged Beef, seasoned and perfectly seared. Served with Penne Marinara. "Best Deal in Town" . The Delmonico is a more flavorful steak because it contains fat. If you want a lean steak, we recommend our filet
Sliced Sirloin Steak
One pound (16 oz) of Choice or Better Sirloin with Cabernet Mushroom Sauce & Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Steak with Pasta
Unfortunately the meatballs which I always look forward to were bland and tasteless
Our waitress was very attentive, my daughter enjoyed her outgoing personality. My meal was very bland and didn’t seem to be fresh. It was room temperature but our appetizers as delicious and hot.
Consistently good service and good food. Nice for casual dining or special occasions
We had excellent service, food, and were spaced very generously from other tables. Felt very comfortable dining here.
Excellent food, excellent service. Great happy hour.
Service was great! Waitress was friendly and courteous. Food was fair. Steak had a lot of grizzle and ravioli was fair. Soup Pasta Fagioli wasn't as good either. Cannoli was great and made the night better. We had been there in the past and was much better then this time was. Probably won’t re-visit anytime soon.
I love it. Very nice and great service. My server was very polite and very attentive
Food is great, and the staff is always friendly and fast.
The website completely mislead to how “classy” this restaurant. My steak was cooked more rare than on the medium rare like I had asked. The waitress never cleared the plates from our appetizer / bread at the beginning of the meal. So, those plates were sitting there the whole meal with food all over them. This place would categorized as just slightly better than a TGI Fridays. Luckily, the price of the meal wasn’t more than 60 dollars so I wasn’t paying a lot for a mediocre dinner. I would recommend going elsewhere for a special occasion.
Delmonicos Steak House was a 10/10 experience, from the food to the service, on a holiday no less. Would definitely eat here again and definitely recommend it to anyone who’s curious, give it a shot! You won’t regret it!
Great food, excellent service, great atmosphere.
I had a great experience while dining with my wife and daughter. The food couldn’t have been better.
Food was excellent service was good
Quality was not what it used to be. Over spiced and over cooked.
We celebrated Valentine's day early. Although many people were entering the restaurant as we arrived, the hostess was very efficient. She found our reservation and flagged a server to take us to our table. The server was about to do something else, but was gracious and courteous as she led us to our table.
The room is spacious and the table placement exceeds the 6' social distancing recommendation. We were not approached by our server right away and people who were seated after us were served first. Our drink and dinner orders arrived in a timely manner. The server was attentive and works very hard.
My husband was slightly disapointed with his steak; but my meal was perfect.
Best value for dinning in Rochester for food service and ambiance
Steak and lobster was delicious, we were a little disappointed with the pasta dish we order but everything else was great. Service was fast and amazing.
We were there for a birthday dinner and it couldn't have been better. Food and our waitress was great. Never had a bad experience.
An amazing meal in a beautiful setting. The music was just perfect. Just loud enough to enjoy but not too loud that we could not enjoy quiet conversation. The wait staff went out of their way to make this a special evening. I have gone here many times and I am never disappointed. I highly recommend this restaurant. The price is a little higher but the food was worth it!!
Although the food was delicious and our server Arielle was wonderful we were very disappointed in the value I ordered the medallions of beef over pasta it was $20 and there were two tiny medallions of meat the size of a baguette of bread slice...two?!?!?!...for $20??? It was not worth the cost for those two tiny pieces of meat we were not happy with that and probably will not return to the restaurant
The food and service is always amazing! Their martinis are the best! We ordered appetizers and entrees and everything was cooked to perfection! It was my son’s 25th birthday and they brought dessert to him at no cost! We go there several times throughout the year.
Sat at the bar and wasn’t greeted until after about 5 or 6 mins had passed. Food was okay. Took 30 mins for my appetizer to come out (calamari and crab cakes). The bartender never explained why it took so long. After she took the appetizer order she didn’t come back to check on us until after we got them. Took 30 mins for lukewarm food. Entrees took another 20 mins. Honestly was a let down. Seem like the staff is more interested in a certain crowd. To be honest I felt like if they didn’t think you would tip well then they paid less attention to you.
Great server. A regular came into the bar area talking about politics. Didn’t even have to explain and the waitress promptly moved us. Food was A1 tasty!
My husband's first time here, and we got sat with Tony and Carmela Soprano! Food was great, very clean and following protocols perfectly. Waiter was wonderful. Loved the idea for blocking off booths with Reserved for Robert DeNiro etc
Food was horrible blan and no flavor. The waitstaff was so disrespectful passing the table spanking each other’s behinds and screaming at each other and laughing.
Our server Erin was great! Food was also great and fast service.
great food, great service and drinks.
Great venue...superb servive...delicious menu! Love this place!
Food was very good for the price. Service was great.
Dinner OK, Veal overcooked. Did not get all of the meal because I asked for the veal w/o sauce. Did not get the pasta with it (I thought it would come as a side dish). Not like O remembered it before. Had a reservation, I was asked to wait in my car.
Food was awesome. Waitress was friendly
Very pricey. Salads and sides not included?
Server was awesome. Food was above average.
On a return visit
Excellent Service and Food. Always a favorite of ours. Our go to restaurant for Holidays and special occasions.
It was great absolutely loved it will be coming back
Freezing cold inside! Food was not as described. Music was blaring in the small room we sat in. We paid over $150 for four people and it was not worth a penny.
Over priced basic food. Our plates came after we ate our appetizer. Little amount of food and prices very high. 4 pieces of asparagus and a steak that was full of fat. Much more fat than meat. I will not return.
My server was lovely, but the food was terrible for the prices. The calamari tasted like it was frozen and the ribeye had zero flavor. I won’t be returning.
Seated near the bar but in a private alcove which saved us from the high noise level. Service was excellent, food was very good but asparagus stalks were tough. Lobster and filet were wonderful. Speciality Cocktails were average but pricey. The tough asparagus was the only complaint. Overall experience was very good. Party of four adults and everyone was satisfied. We have been there many times and 90% of the time, we are not disappointed.
We hadn’t been here for many years, and the quality has declined. Would not return.
Delmonico’s is always a great experience. The regular menu is full of favorites, and the specials are a chance to try something new. The service is delightful. This is a great experience for a regular meal or a special occasion.
Delmonicos Italian Steak House offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (585) 424-4242.
Delmonicos Italian Steak House is rated 4.4 stars by 524 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting bookings at the moment.