Gargiulo's Coney Island
We have a huge dining area, perfect for enjoying a lunch with coworkers or a romantic dinner for two. In addition to lunch and dinner, we also offer private dining rooms that can host anywhere from 20 to 400 people. We also provide catering, so your next corporate meeting, party, wedding reception or event just got a lot tastier!
Get it delivered
Cesare was our waiter and he knows what we want before we know it. Except this time my mom and I took the specials and they were AMAZING and my dad took his usual apple pie and coffee. We always feel like we're walking into a relatives home. They make you feel loved. RoseM
The food was horrible bread was stale served with frozen butter chicken was old and tasted spoiled. They did remove it from the check but very poor quality food. I’m not surprised these red sauce restaurants are never of any quality. I will never return. The dining room is very attractive though.
Gargulio, never disappoints.
Has been heat since my childhood.
Still the shinning star of Coney Island
We are treated like family when we're there. Jerry was out waiter and he anticipated all of our needs. Actually the entire wait staff is great! Rosie M
From the pan-seared mozzarella to the roasted red pepper smothered veal chop, dinner was simply succulent!! The decadent desserts were impossible to resist. Absolutely my favorite restaurant!!
It was amazing! I didn’t know that there was a live band. My family and I celebrated my parents 31st anniversary. The food was amazing. The service was outstanding and we felt good after. Thanks Gargiulo’s
Food was very good, ambiance was nice, decorated for the day. Service was alittle sparce but it was a busy night so 50/50. Live music was a little loud causing people to talk louder
The waiter had so many tables that he forgot about our table. Food and ambiance was good but the service could be better. Possibly going on a regular night and not on a holiday could make your experience better.
Everything was wonderful
The ambiance was nice and the service was great. However, the food was not as I expected. Most people in the group was not satisfied with the taste.
My family has been coming here for the last 60 years great food great service a real dining experience in a classy setting
Love the food..service and vibe
Amazing never disappointed
Always a “go-to” place for an excellent meal, fresh ingredients, good service and friendly faces!
Great food, lovely service. Pianist was wonderful
Everyone enjoyed their meal. One person thought the veal parmigiana could have been better.
Amazing! Would absolutely recommend it!! Looking forward to going back again very soon!!
Delicious meal. The maitre d was very informative and accommodating. Beautifully decorated for the holiday.
Would definitely go back!
Family holiday tradition around Christmas time
Wonderful dinner with old friends
Yearly Christmas trip to Brooklyn
Old school Italian restaurant, good food, service and ambiance.
Resturant is decorated beautifully.
Very much put us in Christmas spirit.
Food and service was horrible. Not like back in the day.
It was our 37th wedding anniversary and it was special. Gargiulo’s restaurant was decorated for Christmas and it was beautiful. I have been there with the guys on several occasions and for other events. My wife loves Gargiulo’s and we will be back.
Great place, great service!!!First time 9 people all ate at the location and everyone enjoyed and raved about it and how i picked a great spot for a special day.
Great service. Good food.
The food was good and service was excellent. Would recommend it.
Food and service were exceptional. The venue is very upscale, and the free parking is a plus.
Louie and Anthony are the best
Everything was perfect from start to finish
My favorite place for a special dinner
We went there for my wife birthday and we made a reservation through open table but when we arrived there was nobody to welcome us and we stand in front of te dining room waiting to get sited. They never checked us in in the first place so i understand that they didn't even recognize about the birthday fact. Food and the server was pretty good. All they need is an hostess/host.
This old school Italian restaurant has been around for a long time. The food is delicious. The wait staff is terrific, attentive and knowledgeable. The affable owners are available and cruise through the restaurant.. At the end of dinner the come around with dice and if your number comes up dinner is on them. The have parking.
Best Italian food in Brooklyn, hands down! The food here has been consistently good for the past 40 years.
What a disappointment! Food was mediocre at best. The chicken soup needed a lot of salt and pepper and the pasta with white clam sauce was salty and unappetizing. The restaurant retains some of its grandeur but the food and the fancy prices no longer match up. Time to move on.
Great from start to finish....! Enjoyed everything especially the food
Excellent food Outstanding service ( you are treated like family
Excellent food and service and I WIN the tombola roll! Dinner was on the house! A true best-of-Brooklyn experience!
35.00 for small lobster tail and 3shrimp and 5 mussells sounds like a lot
My family took me for my birthday celebration, and as usual the food was outstanding. What made the dinner even more special was our waiter, he was amazing - friendly, knowledgeable about the menu and just a joy!! I wish I had asked him his name!! Everyone at our table enjoyed their meal and it was a perfect day!!