Il Mulino Prime - Gramercy
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Proof of vaccination required to dine indoors
Il Mulino Burger
Aged Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions, Gorgonzola, Brioche, fries
prosciutto di parma, beefsteak tomatoes
Food was great, but the service was sub standard. Not our waiters fault, he was wonderful. But had too many tables. We sat outside bc it was a beautiful evening. But saw diners inside turn tables over twice before we got our food. Took two hours to get our dinner served. By the time it arrived, it was too late to eat such a heavy meal and had to take it home. Saw the bartender also serving.
Great service. Incredible food. Best ravioli I have ever had. Nice setting. Quiet street.
Thank you for your kind review. We look forward to seeing you back with us!
Very rude hostess/ manager , food was good . Service outside slow. Def choose midtown location next time
We were very well served by our waiter John seated outside in a nice, segregated area. Great wine selection and timeliness of food delivery was perfect. I would say that the apps were a little skimpy (baked clams & meatballs) yet tasty. My double cut veal chop was perfect! Overall, a non-compromised COVID dining experience.
Thank you Joe for your kind review! We look forward to having you dine with us again soon!
I called TWICE in advance to remind them of a SURPRISE birthday candle for my date. Not only to the hostess (who I spoke with on the phone both times) foolishly wish her a happy birthday as soon we walked in to foil the surprise which I explicitly stated was a secret, but I had to wait over a half hour after our meal and ASK for the birthday candle dessert after all that. Horrible disgusting service for what was such a simple ask!!!!
We were celebrating a special birthday and the staff provided superior service
Christian is so lovely! The food is always excellent and atmosphere calming and bright. My fave restaurant for many years.
Great waiter and delicious pasta and chicken dishes. And excellent Caesar salad. We will return!
Incredible in every way. Food was sublime, best meal by far that we have had in NYC in recent memory. The Caesar salad was light but so flavorful, the filet mignon with truffle butter was the best steak we ever had (all three of us who ordered it agreed), and the the attention and service by our server was super. The wine and bourbon selection was also terrific. Because prices are high, I’d say Il Mulino Prime is more a special occasion rather than every day place, but we will be back for many more occasions!
Service was excellent as was the wine. The food was very good but not outstanding.
We had a great experience! The food was excellent and the service was wonderful!
Service was amazing! Food was hot and fast. Perfect spot for a date
Great food and equally great service. Marcelo is wonderful.
Food was amazing. Feel like we had the best seat in the house. Waiter did an amazing job. Everything was great
Excellent food. Great service. Food served very warm and quickly but did not feel rushed at all
The service was awful. Didn’t like the food at all.
Menu much smaller than true Il Mulino as is restaurant. NY Steak was great as were the baked clams. Wife's fish also very good. Shared very good caesar. Just not the same feeling at all.
The waiter BERATED us at the end of the meal, simply because we were overheard complaining that it was taking too long to process 4 credit cards to split. Very rude, near to the point of the guy being confrontational.
Food was absolutely fantastic and everyone who worked there was super friendly. We will definitely be back!
So disappointing. From dried breadsticks to meh focaccia to an overly salty, overly chopped Caesar and incredibly over salted linguine with white clam sauce, this was one of the worst meals I’ve had in New York. Ever. And it was over $100 per head.
I used to frequent the original Il Mulino in the Village and it was one of my favorite Italian spots in the City. This franchise, separate location delivered even worse than Olive Garden.
Service was excellent, but the food destroyed our night.
We have been fans of Il Mulino for years!! Their various locations are always spot on! This was out first experience at Il Mulino Prime. They did not disappoint!! Marcelllo went from stranger to extended family member in 2 hours. He and the staff treated us like family!! The food was impeccable!! The service was extraordinary!! Can’t wait to come back for another gastronomic extravaganza!! Well done!!!!!
Everything was fantastic - the food, the service, the ambiance.
This was my first time dining at Il Mulino Prime in Gramercy, and I was absolutely blown away. The dining room is absolutely beautiful, and they have a lovely outdoor set-up, as well. The linguine with mixed seafood was simply out of this world, and the tiramisu was amazing. My server Marcelo and the hostess Jessica were both superb, and made certain that my meal was perfect. For a prime dining experience, Il Mulino Prime in Gramercy cannot be topped.
The night started out bad as the hostess was awful didn’t know how to speak to us or other customers Spoke down to us all as if we didn’t know how to make a reservation. Requested to eat inside and she was like nope you did not request inside your sitting outside or nothing. I was like I didn’t request outside and the app does not say must request inside even if you put standard. If the hostess had the common sense and said we know there is issue with the reservation system and are working to correct it, instead she became confrontational and we watched this happen atleast four other times with other diners. Now to the food. All the servers were great and the food was awesome. One of the best steaks I have had in a long time and the pappardelle with the veal ragu was outstanding. Overall great experience. It was even alot of fun sitting outside watching the hostess have to deal with all the customers who expected to sit inside and be pushed outside without any remorse. One set of customers complained so hard they finally got moved inside by another manager. Hostess would not even look at the outside clients in the eyes. Wow a great meal and a free show called Hostess who cares NOT.
Great food and service!
Fast and friendly service, quick vegan modifications ideas
Delicious dinner and excellent sneaky dessert with candle for my boyfriends bday
We enjoyed Il Mulino very much. Good was absolutely delicious. Service excellent.
The whole dining experience From start to finish was wonderful. Our server, Arnold, was so welcoming and on top of everything all night long. All the appetizers we had were Delicious including Cesar salad, tuna tartare, clams oreganato and meatballs. Nothing was left on our plates. I would highly recommend the branzino or prawns over risotto for dinner, although there was not one dish our party ordered that we didn’t love. Arnold gave the best recommendations and was ultra patient with all our questions. He is a a perfect representation of top service. We will definitely be back.
Great food, attentive service, calm environment— a great night!
We ate outside and it was lovely. The food and the service was fantastic.
The food was pretty average. The crowd was almost all out of towners. The cost was high. All in all, we won’t repeat.
Exceptional service!! Staff is engaging and friendly. Stuffed zucchini flowers, ravioli porcini...fantastic. Smartly dressed restaurant and not TOO BIG.. perfect for any occasion.
Great food/wine, great waiter (he had just started a couple weeks earlier), great little enclosed outdoor structure. It is a bit expensive but worth it!
The ambiance was clean and very modern. They have a beautiful space. Our waiter suggested a great bottle of a medium red wine that we finished. The ravioli were delicious but a bit over sauced. The tortellini were also very good — tender and well seasoned. For dessert we ordered the tiramisu and it some of the best we ever had. Overall, this was an excellent Sunday dinner.
Wonderful ! We always enjoy going to the flatiron/garaged you Il Mulino. Warm neighborhood feel and amazing food.
Great for and service. I would go earlier to grab one of three enclosed booths outside until we get covid restrictions lifted.
Great experience, server was incredibly knowledgeable and helpful.
We had such an amazing evening at I’m Mulino. The food was wonderful as always - the homemade pasta particularly - but it was the service that made the meal outstanding and special. It was also the first time we had eaten indoors since the pandemic started and we really appreciated the spacing and the separators between the tables. We’ll be back again soon.
Understaffed and completely chaotic.
Il Mulino Prime - Gramercy offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 777-5314.
Il Mulino Prime - Gramercy is rated 4.5 stars by 180 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting bookings at the moment.