Judge & Jury

icon/ic_reviewCreated with Sketch.
7 reviews
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
£26 to £40
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.

Get it delivered

View all


Leave court-room formality behind and indulge in simple yet refined comfort food classics at Judge & Jury, the freshest of British produce combined with an atmosphere of relaxation and sophistication. Set within one of the most historically significant hotels in London, the restaurant décor encompasses the original features of the former courtroom within the Old Street Magistrate’s Court, creating an ambiance of intrigue and architectural significance. Guests will find themselves surrounded by leather-bound law journals and courtroom memorabilia, evoking a sense of centuries of British legal history, which exist within the hotel walls.

The Judge & Jury staff ensure a personalised and professional experience with extensive knowledge and recommendations. Open for lunch seven days a week and dinner Tuesday to Saturday.
What 7 People Are SayingWrite a review
Overall ratings and reviews
2.9based on all time ratings
25% of people would recommend it to a friend
Sort by
OpenTable Diner
6 reviews
Dined on 22 April 2019

From a relatively small menu, the chicken was tasty and a good substantial plateful. By contrast, we both felt the slate bearing the lamb meal was a sparse offering and, no matter how tasty (and the puree was lovely), represented poor value for money. Even for a light lunch, the amount of food was disappointing.

14 reviews
Dined on 14 February 2019

We booked for Valentines and the Valentines menu, but were give the general menu by the Manager. When we asked the waiter about the Valentines menu he said he would fetch the manager. I wonder if was because we were two men they assumed we weren’t a couple. Anyway the manager was most apologetic and attentive after this.

Overall the service did appear a little chaotic and the other two waiting staff inexperienced.

We had an ok meal, but not very romantic!

The dining room was Courtly.

1 review
Dined on 14 February 2018

I was very happy. It was very quiet as I hoped for, you can really have a conversation or just enjoy your food, that is also well presented and tasty, with flair. I did not see the A la carte Menú, but I was quite impressed with our dishes, service was fast and polite. The Venue it's beautiful and Quirky, Definitely recommended to everyone who likes quiet places

3 reviews
Dined on 17 June 2017

We booked an early evening table on a Saturday. On arrival we were led to the restaurant in the hotel but the only waiter was busy in the next room so we stood around for a while before being acknowledged. He was unaware of the booking (it had been made in the morning) but sat us down at a table of our choice. There was only one other table seated. We we're left with the menu and when the waiter returned for our drinks order we asked if they had a cocktail list. He replied that cocktails are only available if ordered at the hotel bar. When we ordered food it took an age for them to arrive and we were getting peckish so asked the waiter if we could get some bread and butter while waiting. There were side plates and butter knives on the table. After another slow 10 minutes the waiter brought us two slices of toast and a few packets of butter each which made us laugh and slightly concerned about what lay ahead. Fortunately the starters and mains were pleasantly flavorsome. When we asked for the bill after declining desserts the bill was not discounted and the waiter had to take a photo of my reservation on my phone before going into another room and producing the correct bill. After dinner we went over to the bar which looked great with it's refurbished holding cells and jail theme. All in all, nice food, nice dining room shame no one seems to be going.

OpenTable Diner
1 review
Dined on 20 May 2017

Beautiful surroundings but poor staffing and food, sorry this was terrible.

3 reviews
Dined on 19 May 2017

Only ones in restaurant on a Friday evening! Waitress pleasant but had no knowledge of anything on menu!

12 reviews
Dined on 18 March 2017

The restaurant opened recently and because of that it probably needs a little more time to get things right? We thought the food was average , the menu actually a bit boring, nothing overly exciting. There were enough waiters and only a few tables were sold, but they hardly paid attention to us. (They cleared after we finished our mains but we were left alone for almost 20 minutes before anyone offered us coffee or dessert).
But most annoying was that the waiter 'forgot' the special soft-opening rate of 50% discount. We knew when we booked there would be a special rate, which was clearly posted online and there was a big screen at the restaurants entrance as well inviting people for the special rate soft opening. But when the bill came we were charged full price. After I asked the waiter about it he said "he forgot about it" and changed the bill. Really? I wonder how many other (less informed) guests he made pay full price. Bad service.


Judge & Jury is rated 2.9 stars by 7 OpenTable diners.