Liberty Prime Steakhouse
Chickpea mlange, fingerling potatoes, lemon oil
Food was good - my boyfriend and I ordered the kansas city for two and it was more than enough for us to share along with 3 sides. Also, the service was attentive. They also surprised us with a glass of Prosecco for my birthday.
The staff was very accommodating when we arrived and seated us at a better table. It was the birthday of one of our guests and they sent a complimentary dessert to celebrate. Liberty Prime is by far the best steak house in Jersey City -- looks like there have been some staff changes, but the services was still really good and the food is excellent. They seemed to follow safety protocols, too (took our temperature at the door, always wore masks, tables were distant). We had such a great night, it felt "normal" again.
Birthday dinner with the family
Nice quiet place. The food was very good along with the service. Definitely will attend more often, and would recommend.
Had a wonderful dinner! Delicous steak and the best creamed spinach i've ever had. Great ambiance and service!
Steak was ordered medium came out well done. Unfortunately liked the place but going to a steak house and it coming out not as expected ruined the first time experience.
Not one for desert but it was so good thank goodness I wore my sketchy pants lol
Service was verrrrrry slow. Food tasty but not hot
Did outdoor dining. Our server was friendly and attentive. Appetizers were good as well as the dessert.
Unfortunately the porterhouse for 2 and prime rib were both way overcooked. We decided not to return it as we were too hungry plus we hate having to do that anyway. We really had high hopes despite the hit-or-miss reviews, but it turns out they are that way for a reason.
This restaurant is on a lane of its own. They have good food but don’t compare it to one of the finer steakhouses. We also had our wedding reception here a year ago and that was Phenomenal. Our guest still rave about the food. Not sure if COVID had caused some changes in the kitchen.
Was pretty disappointed thinking this would be a NYC style steakhouse. Our server was AWFUL. May have been his first night on the job. Overall the staff very inexperienced. Hostess sat us right next to someone else....not cool in this era of social distancing. Steak was overcooked...asked for medium it was well. Sides were decent and the drinks really good...but overall not worth the price.
The service was very very poor. I understand that it was only a week for dining in but the food drinks and service was unacceptable. Reservation was at 730pm. We were seated fast but after that. It went down hill. Drinks were disgusting sent them back twice. Took our appetizers 45 mins to get. Waiter was out of site out of mind. When we finally were able to place our dinner order. It took another 45mins to receive it. It was our first time dinning here. We will give it another try after this whole Covid-19 pandemic is over. 2020 sure has brought a lot to surface.
It felt more like a bar place than a steak house. Bathrooms were not clean and the staff using them didn’t close door nor flushed after using them. We walked out of restaurant and decided not to eat there
The waiter was not attentive. He never took our coffee order. He only cared about the table next to us. Disappointing service for an expensive meal.
Second time we’ve been there. Both for occasions and have never been disappointed.
Quiet Sunday afternoon lunch
Food good quality, decent sized portions
Always great service
Ordered a $40 NY Strip medium-rare and it was served definitely medium if not medium-well. Wasn’t going to send it back but the steak was dry so I asked to have it removed; NOT taken off the bill-just didn’t want it at the table. Another server or chef, I’m unsure of who he was because he didn’t identify himself, just came out in defense of the steak; was so insulting we just asked for the check and left. We would have stayed, ordered more drinks, desserts, AND paid for the obviously overcooked mistake of a steak but after that; they didn’t deserve my money. The serving staff was superb but if you’re unclear of steak temperatures and insult your customers-I can’t recommend.
A bit concerned one of my waiters didn't have the mask fully on their noise.
I ordered the Ribeye and they served me a NY steak cap. It was hard as a rock. They charged me $65 for the wrong dinner. Don't recommend.
A neighborhood favorite because of the food, service, and proximity to my home. Unfortunately during my latest visit the weather turned bad and, since we aren't yet allowed to eat indoors this could have ruined the entire meal. However, the staff were amazingly accommodating. They locked the front entrance and moved our table under the awning which overhangs that entrance so that we could enjoy the rest of our meal without getting soaked by the rain. These guys are fantastic. I hope they continue to thrive despite the pandemic because the neighborhood would be less enjoyable without Liberty Prime.
THEY WERE CLOSED! NO NOTICE OUTSIDE THEIR DOORS! ONLINE SHOWED THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO OPEN @ 11AM, WE ARRIVED 11:45AM. WE CALLED AND TGEUR VOICEMAIL ONLY ASKED TO LEAVE A MESSAGE, NO BUSINESS HOURS ADVISED! BAD EXPERIENCE!
Great food and even better service! The meat was delicious but the sides and desserts took it to another level
Great experience even with all that is currently going on with Covid-19. The services and food were great! Though this is technically a steakhouse, i ALWAYs get their Salmon SO GOOD!!!
Amazing. Great service. Our waiter was so kind and attentive
I would but if in the bar/lounge area only. As a regular at many steakhouses in the city I found Liberty Prime to be very pricy for what you get. Service was good, but the meat was subpar. The only reason why I didn’t say anything was because it was a birthday and the in-laws were in town
Lower level seating sucks and the noise from the bar ruined the evening
I’d be back for sure-
But for the bar menu and cocktails
Not full dinner
Positives: Amount of food was big! Two of us ordered 1 appetizer, 1 steak for 2, and one side dish and it was more than enough food. Also, service wasn't bad.
Negatives: The qualify of the steak. We had a Porterhouse for 2, and it was below average. The cut had too much fat and muscles and other things inside. One side of the bone was great, the other was bad. Also, the bread (cornbread I believe) that was delivered after arrival was very dry - almost inedible.
I came here with a group of 10 for a birthday dinner and it was amazing. The service is great! The food was prepared quickly! We all really enjoyed ourselves and we plan on coming back. Thanks for everything :)
Nice place for a business lunch. Good menu variety. Reasonable price points for a quality restaurant
The food wasn’t good at all. We spent $300 on a basic meal. Would not recommend.
The food was absolutely delicious.
Services were good but foods were a little slow. Overall it was a great experience!
Good food. Nice atmosphere. Water was solid and overall service was great!
We ordered the porterhouse for two, apps and drinks. This was our first time here. It had a nice vibe and friendly waiter. So-so service but what ruined it was our porterhouse ordered medium rare was mostly well done, some sections were rare. Steak was very gristly and tasted old. We had been wanting to try this place since it opened. : (. We were so hopeful this place would be on par with New York steakhouses but unfortunately the only thing that compared were the prices.
The meat was cooked to perfection, the appetizers were amazing and starting with bone marrow is highly recommended!!!
The head bartender Diana was amazing - very attentive and made me a drink to my liking - now known as the Desert of Passion! (She let me name it!)
Hopefully it makes it to the menu!
We went for restaurant week. Good food and a good price.
Great food and great time!!!
Lively atmosphere, decent food but definitely overpriced. Doesn't hold a candle to a lot of other steak houses. We had to request both steaks we ordered to be sent back to the kitchen for a few more minutes as they were undercooked compared to how we ordered them
Excellent staff service and great ambiance. Great spot for large groups. There were confusion with two of our brunch ordered that were supposed to go to a different table but the staff rectified the issue. I was surprised that the brought up basket of Krispy Kreme Donut. Great partnership with the new local Krispy Kreme factory in Jersey City! 😋🍩
Liberty Prime Steakhouse offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (201) 333-3633.
Liberty Prime Steakhouse is rated 4.2 stars by 454 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting bookings at the moment.