Outstanding food and service, cannot wait to return!

Food very well presented and service was fantastic! Drinks were very good too. Love the atmosphere!

It took well over an hour to get our meals. They were cold, not very good and overpriced.

It was a great night out! Great drinks and great food. Loved the soup and inside of the restaurant is beautiful.

Great place, great food. Good place to go. Enjoyed it.

Good food but pricey

We enjoyed our valentines dinner this year. My wife got the salmon en croute. And I got the filet mignon.

I really like this place. Been here a few times prior and enjoyed every meal I ever had. Unfortunately, this one was different. My family attended for my birthday and grabbed a 4 pm spot. The service was good, which I have come to expect. The food however, somewhat disappointing. I had the prime rib which was done as asked - mostly. The meat was cold in spots. Not just cool but cold. The creamed spinach was not really creamed. It was steamed but barely had any cream. The potatoes were decent but nothing extraordinary. My spouse had the eggplant parm. It was pretty basic and the sauce not overly flavorful. The kids had grilled cheese, fries and I also grabbed a shrimp app for my daughter. $120 later, we walked away disheartened. I won’t say that I would never come back. I will say that I will think twice about where I can spend $120 on 4 meals or even $60 for the same quality.

Excellent food with great service!

It was the perfect setting for a romantic Valentine's day dinner. The staff were remarkably attentive, we weren't rushed through dinner, the drinks were excellent, and the food was delicious...

Favorite restaurant!

Love this Great Restaurant! I love the ambience, the fire, the cozy atmosphere. The chef is amazing. Food is always cooked to perfection and the variety of flavors are what I look forward to the most!

Excellent food, and very friendly staff. Definitely going to be back

everyone's meal was fine/the Duck breast was really nice with rice and vegetables .egg plant dish my wife had for dinner was also fine.

The shrimp appetizer was very small and disappointing but everything else was wonderful. I had the tuna special my friend had the tenderloin pasta, we loved it. Cute place, warm and cozy!

Cold food long wait for watery soup . People seated after us for meals before our soup. Main course cold fried rice awful will not be back really wanted to like it had great reviews

Just a great cozy place...great food and cocktails!! Can’t miss with this place!!

Last time I order your Fish Fry was Huge ad delicious,
This time I order the comfort food batter Chicken with the Sweet Chili ty was great!
Only one thing they Burn my French fry’s I could not eat them, chicken was on top of them so I didn’t notice them at first, them the waitress was very nice and asked if she could put another order in for me but, my dinner was already here. He chef should have never let them come out like that.
The eggplant Napoleon was excellent made up for the Fry’s.

The quality of the food and friendly staff make this a great place. It's nice to have a 5 star meal in a small town.

This restaurant was super cute and cozy inside! Would most definitely come back

Servers were attentive and pleasant. Wish we had been seated in the main area rather than the larger spacious room for more "atmosphere." Did accommodate my gluten free requests.

Excellent meal for Friday Night Date night. Good beer and wine selection. Apple fritter dessert topped off a good night.

Made a reservation 2-3 early and basically only seating available was the loft that felt cold. The beef stroganoff was very chewy and not tender. The steak was cooked to order and was acceptable

One of our favorite restaurants. Always consistent in all areas - service and food. We bring our young daughter (and sometimes one of her friends). The servers go out of their way to make her feel special. The owner is always greeting people when they enter and leave. The only request I would have is being allowed to pick sides rather than have them picked for me. I would also like to see a menu with the draft beer selections and a description with them. Love CM!

Absolutely incredible! Food was great, service was outstanding, and the venue is unique and rustic!

Wonderful and delicious

It was a great experience. Everything was of great quality. Service and food exceptional.

had a wonderful dinner in a restaurant because of the orange zone in our area, we loved everything especially the teds shrimp and our waitress was amazing. we will be back at some time to enjoy the wonderful food.

Wedge salad was fantastic! Plate Portions were huge and delicious!!

The Colden Mill is a unique place. Quality food, excellent service and a building with a colorful history. The wooden timbers, fireplace and collection from a bygone era makes one feel at home. I know this building because I used to go there with my grandfather to buy grain and feed for his farm in Colden many years ago. The owners have done justice retaining much of the original structure. Excellent rating!

Great. Food our 2nd time there everything was great left full and had a few nice cocktails service was great they practiced covid. Protocol to the letter. Will go back

We have been a patron of The Colden Mill for over 20 years.....even through all of the changes over the years it maintains it ambiance and wonderful food..

Our family of 12 went to the Colden Mill for Christmas Eve dinner. They had a shorter menu, but the options included something for everyone. The food was excellent. The whole restaurant was decorated beautifully and the service was very good. Highly recommend.

Amazing atmosphere, great service, excellent food.

Fine dining with a variety of specials including fish, scallops and filet. The scallops were delicious. Wine selection isn't extensive but something available for all tastes. We had a nice evening. Have been there many times in past years and will be there again. They are following pandemic guidelines and we felt safe.

Great options at all price points. Comfortable and accommodating.
Great chef!

awesome awesome awesome awesome awesome awesome awesome

Colden Mills was a delight in these awful times. Decor was wonderful as was food. Only drawback was being sat at the ONLY high top table in the place!! Food service was a bit slow but worth the wait.

Great meal with very interesting specials every week.

Great, serene and quiet and quaint location. Our server was great. The food was outstanding.