The New York Restaurant
Dinner was delicious & service was efficient and pleasant. Thank you.
Staff very friendly!
This was a lovely lunch after a tour of the Thomas Cole house. Such a great beer selection in addition to delicious food! Very Polish influence!
Our experiences at The New York Restaurant get better and better. This time we opened with a bottle of pinot gris (always auspicious) and Polish beer (of course). Two of us ordered all thing Polish, while the other two explored the Euro-Italian menu offerings. As ever, no one was disappointed.
Be sure to stay away from the air conditioning unit that is set at 62F. Food was excellent, service was a little slow and the price was a little higher than expected.
The food was over cooked and tuff. I was disappointed. The place was crowded and very noisy. I have eaten there before and it was good. Maybe they were having a bad night.
Birthday dinner for me while visiting my son
Always delicious food and great service
We had the swordfish which was on special and it really should not have been served
My only complaint was it got very warm while we were eating. It was a busy night though so maybe all of the people....
I took clients to dinner and the food was delicious! Wonderful service! Everything was homemade. I will be back!
Our first visit on recommendation of another. Don’t get an appetizer or you won’t be able to finish main. If I lived in Catskill, this would be my bar.
The food is always consistently good. Nice selection. The matre'd and the waitress were very pleasant and attentive. Unfortunately, that evening there seem to be issues with the AC keeping up with the very hot night so it was a bit uncomfortable, but that's not usually the issue other times I have eaten here. Nice local spot with reliably good food and fair prices. Don't miss it!
Food was not up to the usual. Service was a bit slow. All of which is not a standard for this place. Past few times were much better.
Stopped here on our way to the Berkshires from NJ. Found by using OT. Not crowded for a Saturday afternoon, tough we had to wait quite awhile for our food. Besides that, good service, great food (had the Reuben). Nice walk afterwards around the very quaint town. Would go back.
What a wonderful surprise. Varied menu with the Polish delicacies the highlight-- excellent pirogues, cabbage, kielbasa. Pleasant surrounds. Sunday noon there was quiet jazz with an excellent singer.
Loved it. The food is original and yummy. The staff is very friendly. Overall we had a great time.
We found this restaurant while scrolling through the open table app. Not having any knowledge before we went in with an open mind. We were more than pleasantly surprised! The service was great and the food was exceptional. I highly recommend the garlic Parmesan fries as an appetizer the sauce they came with was amazing. Great experience overall!!!
Outstanding in every way
Terrific experience. Great variety in the menu- all of it really good. It’s a satisfying place to be. Loved the music.
We had a great time! Our waitress was fabulous. The food was so good and one of us had the BEST dessert ever. It was the cookie sundae with ice cream ... I don't remember the name of it but WOW! To die for! Reasonable prices and good food. We had a blast!
Would return ! It was most enjoyable. Thank you for choosing Catskill.
Took 90 minutes to get our food, when restaurant was empty. No one came over to explain or apologize for the wait. And when the food came out, there were mistakes. Host was rude when we expressed our concerns. Just awful. Never going back.
We had a great time. The food and service was excellent. We found it very loud at times and it was a bit dark to read the menu. We previously reviewed the menu.
Great place overall. Terrific food, decor casual but smart, friendly informed service. Totally worth a stop if in Hudson Valley or detour!!
We were 5 friends having an all too infrequent outing. The food was excellent. Service was friendly.
My only comment is that the lighting is a little too dark & the Menu font a little too small (old eyes)
Overall we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner
We shall absolutely return
Wonderful restaurant. Found on a whim one Sunday and had an amazing brunch. 2 months later we'd been wanting to come back and try dinner, and so glad we did. Excellent food. Fresh and perfect temperature.
Consider yourself warned now, ordering the cauliflower wings IS A MUST if you want to leave with the utmost happiness and delight. If you don't like vegetables, ORDER THE CAULIFLOWER WINGS! If you're vegan, ORDER. If you're a carnivore, ORDER. Understand? Don't make the appetizer choice so painful for yourself. The portion is just right for 2, a group of 3 or more will likely battle to the death 'sharing'.
From the start to end this restaurant is a must!!! The food is fresh and great healthy options, and also many options for vegetarians and vegans. Drinks are great and most of all service and ambiance is first class. My server Adriana was the best. She knows the menu and has a fluent way of describing your options.
Excellent Food was great. Highly recommend!! Natasha and Kevin are great hosts
Our server was friendly and attentive as was all the staff we interacted with. The drinks were great and the specials were inventive. The bananas foster crepes were so amazing. When it came time to pay and we all had cards (party of 5) they were understanding and willing to work with us splitting the bill.
Great food.... excellent service
Amazing lemon cake!
We frequently visit this excellent restaurant and we live in Saratoga Springs! It’s worth the ride to us...Pierogis, brisket, burger, kielbasa, desserts..all excellent!!
First time in the area and this place was recommended to us by airbnb host, the food was great! the Host was very welcoming as well. We would definitely come back!
Everything was great! I wish they kept the previous look of the restaurant though.
The New York Restaurant is a great place to enjoy a great meal and craft cocktails. The staff is very accommodating and professional. I highly recommend and I look forward to my next visit!
Consistently good food and libations. Staff and owner Natasha always provide a great product and service. Kudos!. Thanks JJ for making our St Pattys day fun!
Brett and Kim
Great place to go in Catskill. Lovely vibe. Great for dates OR a family dinner.
Had a good time. We’re from out of town and the host didn’t seem excited to see outsiders in the off-season but rather very excited when a local came in. I tried to understand and put it behind me. It did stick out to me throughout my meal that the first person to welcome you to the establishment should be welcoming instead of losing interest immediately. What did stick out positively during the meal was the food. The food was amazing, my girlfriend and I shared black truffle and Parmesan pirogies which were incredible and buffalo wings. For entrees I had tour of Poland and my GF had the factory burger both were great (I tried some burger😋). Portions were big enough that you could eat everything on your plate if you were very hungry but we were able to bring some home which I was happy about. The ambiance was nice, it’s a moderately noisy and was had an enjoyable atmosphere. Price was standard and value was standard to above average. Enjoyed my time there and will most definitely be coming back for more black truffle and Parmesan pirogies.