What Insiders Are Saying
A cash only, no reservations, popular East Village Italian establishment.
This special eclectic restaurant has a wonderful menu. They serve great salads, fresh homemade pasta and delicious entrees. The wine list is extensive. I love dining here.
Lemon pasta is the BOMB
Great outdoor seating, pricey menu means bring a lot of cash!
I was here in March for my birthday and when my friend was in this past weekend from London, I knew she'd love it as much as I did. The waiter brought out bread and their delicious spread of whole white beans in a garlicky sauce. We shared the prosciutto and fig appetizer which was yummy and then we both ordered the Spaghetti al Limone which is a very simple dish of spaghetti with butter, lemon and Parmesan cheese. One of the best pasta dishes I've ever had! Added a little fresh pepper and we were both in heaven. Then we shared the hazelnut panna cotta with warm chocolate sauce and fresh berries. Needless to say, we left there stuffed, but happy!
This place never disappoints. We always make it a point to visit whenever we are in New York. It doesn’t matter what you order, everything is absolutely delicious!!! And the service is incredible. This last visit we were celebrating my 7 year old daughters birthday and they treated her day wonderfully. Absolutely a must whenever you’re in the city!!! Thanks for everything
Delightful dining with tasty food. Delicious veal meatballs appetizer and superb mushroom salad. Excellent service. Music was too loud at start but lowered to pleasant level. Will return.
Très bon restaurant !
La milanaise c’est une folie et
Ils sont adorables !
AMAZEBALLSSSSS ! Had a great meal and staff was awesome !
Burratta was sour. The chicken was eh. The only good item was the lemon pasta. The service was lousy they were too busy taking pictures of food probably for instagram. I had heard good things but my family was very disappointed. We have been to little Frankie’s and love it but supper is poor.
I ordered the tagliatelle bolognese and it was awful and I’ve eaten some awful things. I would expect more from an establishment like this. I realize it could have been an off night or a different chef was cooking but how hard is it to have a little taste before they send out the food? The sauce tasted really bland and almost sweet with no garlic. I’ve never had a bolognese sauce like that. My friends did not enjoy their meals either. I was really disappointed with the whole experience. I specifically picked this place for my birthday dinner because of all the good reviews. I am embarrassed that I took my friends here and wasted their money. The only good thing was the tiramisu.
Make a reservation as this is a popular restaurant. Great food and great service is what keeps this place hopping. Looking forward to going back.
The food was delicious; however, the service was severely lacking. Our server hardly came by during the course of the meal and we waited 15 minutes for our tiramisu because he forgot to run the dessert. Luckily, he took the tiramisu off the bill, but the lack of timely service was frustrating considering the food was delicious.
The food, service and ambiance were all incredible!!
Supper always a vacation favorite when visiting the big city! Easy way to impress friends when you’re taking them out!
Awesome food and service!
Amazing food, wonderful service, and overall incredible experience. Can't wait to go back! Thank you, Supper!
Food was very good, but pricey. Took only cash so with a larger party that was inconvenient
We were a party of 4 who sat outside on a Sunday for a birthday brunch. We opted for the 3 for 1 drinks for brunch. The mimosa was almost pure orange juice. The bellini had a little more sparkling white wine. The coffee was very good, but pricey. The brunch menu was fine. The service was a delight.
Celebrated our daughter’s birthday, a family favorite. Did not disappoint. Everyone enjoyed the wine, octopus, bolognese, spaghetti limone and more. Service was excellent. Cozy and energetic space, we thoroughly enjoyed it. Can’t wait to go back.
I travel all over and their prices were ridiculously expensive.
The food was absolutely phenomenal. Would go again.
Amazing food, tiny quarters. Hard working staff!
Good food, very cozy place for a solid meal, little expensive though for what it is
Fantastic traditional Italian food. Pastas were delicious.
Great food and hospitable staff.
However, we were concerned that the restaurant had a “Grade Pending” health score.
Amazing, authentic italian food. We got reservations thankfully because the place was packed. Our server was very friendly and even offered us a free dessert because we couldnt choose between the tiramisu and the panacotta (which were both so good!)
I recommend this restaurant, they have nice choices and the food is delicious!
Kale gnocchi is the best I've ever had. Such a great spot.
My husband and I had a wonderful dinner here. Our server was absolutely lovely and thoughtful and added to our enjoyment of the evening. I read a number of reviews (of this and other restaurants) before choosing to make a reservation here and I cannot agree with any of the negative comments that people have made, not that there are many. The food was outstanding and not unreasonably priced. The setting is charming and nothing and no one was pretentious. The staff were gracious and went above and beyond to ensure we had a nice time. For instance, I couldn’t decide between two appetizers so our waitress just brought us both and only charged us for one. We live in a very foodie city and it is rare, even when we travel out of the country, that we have meals that rival what we can get at home. Supper did! We will most definitely return the next time we are in the city.
And for what is worth, I couldn’t tell you the last time I wrote a review. I so rarely do but our experience here compelled me to take the time to write. I would give it more than 5 stars if I could!
The table was small, the restaurant was nothing to write home about, and the service was just attentive but nothing more, and it’s cash only. I felt like I was in Europe, but I wasn’t so I wasn’t impressed by the allure of Supper, a restaurant in too Far East in the EV for my liking, but I would go back again and again for the food. I enjoyed everything down to the sauce my lasagna left over. While it was the best lasagna bolognese in the city, i do believe my dinner overall was overpriced, but alas, it’s New York
I apologize in advance ... this review is probably going to offend a lot of people, and I wouldn't normally go out of my way to write a negative review, however after being misguided by previous reviews for Supper on this website AND being recommended this restaurant by a friend for my birthday dinner I felt compelled to write an honest no bs review.
The general ambiance is fine (standard for East Village Manhattan) but to say the food is just far too oily is an understatement. Spaghetti shouldn't splatter grease in ten different directions each time you twirl your fork before taking a bite. For reference, I ordered the Spaghetti al Limone, and could hardly taste any flavor other than the oil the food was cooked in. I was hungry after working through lunch so carried on eating, until I found what looked like a puddle of grease at the bottom of the bowl hiding beneath the spaghetti - at which point I stopped... There was legitimately more oil in the bottom of my pasta bowl than the olive oil bowl we were given with the bread basket when we sat down for the meal.
If you enjoy greasy "Italian" food and want to increase your risk of a heart attack then, by all means, come here, but if you want to taste the flavor of anything besides oil and grease then head somewhere else.
Food was amazing, service was great. It's fairly noisy inside, but it depends on which table you get. I would definitely go back!
Best food I’ve had in a long time. Great anniversary celebration.
It’s simply the best! The food is delicious, the setting lovely, and the staff always accommodating. Try the chicken parmigiana or any of their pastas.
Met friends who live in the neighborhood. Little did I know it was their favorite restaurant, and for good reason! The food and service was outstanding!
The service was so great, it made our day! Can’t wait to go back!
Birthday. Great good at an affordable price.
Came for my birthday because I wanted Italian food like I had growing up. Just like my father and grandmother would make. This hit the mark on every level right down to the birthday serenade I got from pretty much the entire staff. I love this place!