Diners' Choice: Great for fine wines restaurants in South Yorkshire

OpenTable

Updated 05 November 2026

Looking for restaurants with the most notable wine lists in South Yorkshire? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyses nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favourite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you book, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Antler Grill and Wine

4.9

4.9 (480)

£26 to £40

Persian

Sheffield

About the restaurant

Antler is a small family run Persian restaurant located in S6, a stone’s throw from Hillsborough Stadium.

Here you can indulge in our signature charcoal grilled kebabs, fragrant saffron-infused rice, and Mediterranean small plates.

Our chef Meysam seamlessly marries the rich flavours of the ancient Silk Road with an exquisite selection of wines.

Enjoy the warmth of our hospitality in our cosy dining area, and on hot days, relax in our beautiful garden.

Top review

Helen

Dined 5 days ago

It was a lovely evening with great service. The food was delicious as always.

Restaurant Elm

4.9

4.9 (163)

£26 to £40

British

Sheffield

About the restaurant

3 AA Rosettes and selected for the MICHELIN Guide 2026 – Restaurant Elm is where fine dining drops the formality and turns up the vibe.

Led by award-winning Chef Nathan Wall, it’s a place where creativity, flavour, and ease come together effortlessly. The menu is seasonal, refined, and full of surprises, precision cooking without the pretence. A tight, cleverly curated wine list showcases producers who care about craft, while the team keeps things warm and genuine.

**Dietary Requirements**

Please inform us in advance of any dietary requirements, including vegetarian preferences, by noting them on your reservation.

Whilst we are able to accommodate gluten-free diets, **we are unable to cater for guests with coeliac disease** due to the risk of cross-contamination in our kitchen.

**Please note:** We are also unable to accommodate dairy-free diets.

Top review

Delyth

Dined 4 days ago

Absolutely stunning food. Seasonal, unami and beautifully presented.

La Rustica

4.8

4.8 (1155)

£26 to £40

Italian

Doncaster

About the restaurant

WE REOPEN ON 12 SEPTEMBER 2024

We look forward to welcoming you back to dine with us.

We are proud to breathe new life back into the oldest Italian restaurant in Doncaster.
Our aim is to deliver quality, affordable Mediterranean cuisine with a contemporary twist – all served in a unique & relaxed environment.

Top review

Mark

Dined 5 days ago

Absolutely outstanding experience at La Rustica Italian Restaurant! We booked a table for two and from start to finish everything was fantastic. The atmosphere was amazing, the food was exceptional, and the whole experience was spot on. We had the pasta with meatballs and the slow-cooked beef tagliatelle, and both dishes were absolutely delicious. Beautifully cooked, full of flavour and clearly made with quality ingredients. A brilliant restaurant with a lovely atmosphere and food that really stands out. We couldn't fault anything and would highly recommend La Rustica to anyone who loves authentic Italian food. We will definitely be returning. An absolute gem! 10/10!

La Boca

4.8

4.8 (2008)

£26 to £40

Argentinian

Doncaster

About the restaurant

Welcome you into our beautiful, 60-seat restaurant situated in the heart of Doncaster. We know that you will enjoy the incredible décor, inspired by the honey bees of Argentina: lush gold accents, shades of striking cerulean and hexagonal patterns echo throughout.

La Boca is the ultimate dining experience, from the lively indoor atmosphere and finest cuts of meat, to our close-knit team of friendly, helpful and reliable staff. Relaxed afternoons and flamboyant evenings are equally enjoyable when spent with us. Our stylish and well designed interior secures a venue you’ll visit time and time again.

Pleae note that for bookings of 6 or more and for special occasions eg Valentine's day a deposit is payable on booking. This is non-refundabke if changes are made with less than 48 hours notice.

Please note that we add a discretionary service charge of 10%, which is shared amongst all staff.

Top review

David

Dined 6 days ago

From personal recommendations we expected the best, and we got it. What a delightful first personal introduction to La Boca. The restaurant in all respects, choice of food, service and price went beyond our expectations. One of my guests remarked how nice to build up a vision on how an evening should go and leave with no disappointment whatsoever. We will hope to repeat the exercise are we able to get in! Thank you all, exceptional. David W.

Gillson's Brasserie

4.8

4.8 (91)

£26 to £40

Contemporary French

Sheffield

About the restaurant

From the team behind Gills & Co and the Gillmont, Gillson's brings the spirit of the traditional brasserie to Ecclesall Road, Sheffield, serving classic dishes, quality ingredients and warm hospitality from lunch into the evening.

Choose from:
Prix Fixe Lunch Menu - available Monday - Saturday for bookings between 12pm and 3pm
A La Carte Dinner Menu - available Monday - Saturday for bookings between 12pm and 9pm
Sunday Lunch Menu - available Sunday for bookings between 12pm - 7pm

A note about dogs:
As Gillson’s is a full-service restaurant, we don’t allow dogs inside, with the exception of assistance dogs. If you’re out with your four-legged friend, they’re very welcome at our sister venues, Gills & Co and The Gillmont.

Top review

Clare

Dined 3 days ago

We really enjoyed our family Sunday roast meal. The service was great , good was tasty and portions were perfect. Highly recommend x

Assembly at The Schoolrooms

4.7

4.7 (213)

£25 and under

Bistro

Sheffield

About the restaurant

Assembly is our late night, village Bar & Bistro in the heart of Low Bradfield, working the evening shift on behalf of The Schoolrooms.

We are open for bistro evenings Wednesday to Saturday night and serve Sunday roasts all day, every Sunday.

Our talented local chefs, carefully curate every menu to showcase the best of Sheffield and our agricultural roots, putting a modern twist on traditional British dining.

Our beautifully decorated interiors and friendly team provide a superb dining experience for all occasions.

Winner of Best Newcomer at Westside Restaurant Awards 2023, short-listed for Best New Restaurant at Exposed Awards 2024 and Winner of Best Bistro at Westside Restaurant Awards 2025!

Come to Bradfield and see what all the fuss is about.

Top review

Jason

Dined 3 days ago

It was our first time and the food & venue was excellent. Really enjoyed it and would definitely return.

Discover more

Experience

New Years Eve - 5 Course Tasting Menu

La Velvetta

4.7

4.7 (86)

£26 to £40

Steakhouse

Doncaster

About the restaurant

Created for those who appreciate exceptional food in a stylish and welcoming setting, our restaurant offers an elevated dining experience where quality, flavour and outstanding hospitality come together. Dress code is smart casual.

We take pride in serving the finest fresh ingredients, with dishes to suit everyone, but with expertly prepared premium dry-aged steaks at the heart of our menu.

Whether you're joining us for a relaxed lunch, a family celebration or an evening with friends, you'll enjoy an elegant dining experience. For your convenience, free parking is available directly in front of the restaurant.

Top review

Michelle

Dined on 3 Nov 2026

Everything about our visit was absolutely fabulous. Friendly, attentive and professional staff. Thank you Aby! Food exceptional! Efficient service! A lovely touch by giving the happy couple, who recently got engaged, a on the house glass of Prosecco each to mark their celebration. Thank you so much. We can’t wait to come again.

Piccolino - Sheffield

4.6

4.6 (465)

£26 to £40

Italian

Sheffield

About the restaurant

World-famous as the ‘steel city’, Sheffield was famed for its industry in the 1900s, and remains a cutting-edge city to this day. Sheffield boasts independent microbreweries and a diverse range of pubs, cafes and bars. There is also a thriving live music scene and a calendar of events and exhibitions to suit every taste. Sheffield is also home to a wide range of excellent cafes and restaurants.
Piccolino, an authentic Italian Restaurant, is proud to be a fixture of Sheffield’s dining scene. Located on Millennium Square, Piccolino boasts an open kitchen, cocktail bar and large terrace featuring a fully retractable roof to ensure the ultimate alfresco experience rain or shine!
We visit the regions, meet the producers and are committed to sourcing the best quality ingredients. Our passion for provenance is at the forefront of our menu, which incorporates the best and freshest seasonal produce, Italian cheeses, meat and seafood, all delivering pure classic Italian flavours.

Top review

AdamGold

Dined on 31 Oct 2026

Lovely restaurant and staff were great, the food was beautiful also

Discover more

Experience

Express Lunch

Experience

A Taste of Piccolino : Tasting Menu

Experience

Signature Festive Menu

Cafe Bar Concerto

4.5

4.5 (350)

£25 and under

British

Doncaster

About the restaurant

The stylishly art deco Cafe Bar Concerto is situated within the grand surroundings of The Earl of Doncaster Hotel. With its glass paneled Cocktail Bar and sunburst glass chandeliers, the restaurant offers a truly unique dining experience.

Specialising in modern cuisine, the Cafe Bar Concerto offers Lunch, Dinner and Afternoon Tea alongside as well as an excellent drinks range including Lagers, Beers, Spirits, Wines, Champagne and Prosecco.

Top review

Roy

Dined on 16 Oct 2026

Whenever we visit Doncaster we always make sure we book to eat at the fabulous Earl of Doncaster 😁.

Discover more

Sunday Lunch - Live music from 'The Duets'

Estabulo - Barnsley

4.3

4.3 (1562)

£26 to £40

Brazilian Steakhouse

Barnsley

About the restaurant

Located on Regent Street in the heart of Barnsley, Estabulo brings the vibrant spirit of Brazilian dining to the town with an unforgettable restaurant experience. Our authentic rodizio menu offers continuous tableside service of expertly grilled premium meats, carved directly onto your plate by our skilled passadores, alongside unlimited access to our gourmet salad bar featuring fresh seasonal salads, hot dishes, and traditional Brazilian sides.

For guests looking for something different, our à la carte menu showcases a variety of carefully crafted dishes, from premium steak and burgers to signature favourites. Recently enhanced with our Café de Brazil additions, inspired by the world-famous French butter sauce with a Brazilian twist, these flavour-packed dishes bring a bold new experience to the menu and are not to be missed.

Top review

Matt

Dined 4 days ago

Excellent service, and the food was top class. Brilliant evening.

Discover more

Experience

The Rodizio Experience

Explore Diners' Choice best of South Yorkshire