Slow-Roasted Prime Rib of Beef
Seasonal vegetables, whipped yukon gold potatoes, natural jus
Pan-Roasted Local Organic Chicken
Buttermilk corn pure, ragout of fingerling potatoes and dandelion greens, maple cider jus
Goat Cheese Salad, Caramelized Apple
Spicy pastry, prosciutto ham and port wine
Food was good, service was good, will go back. Had a great first time experience and will return. It is on the pricy side but it can be expected for fine dinning. Expect dinner for 2 with no alcohol and dessert to be almost $100. On the other hand, food was amazing.
Outstanding food, as always! Highly recommended for any special occasion. The patio’s lovely in good weather.
This is a place where you get the impression that every single thing served is not an afterthought but rather has received careful consideration. A rare combination of excellent food and service and outstanding and tasteful ambience. Always a satisfying experience.
Sidney Tavern never disappoints. The food and atmosphere are always wonderful! Nicole took care of us and the service was great!
First time at the Sidney. My wife and I like to find unique one-off non-chain restaurants. Took her there for her birthday. Everything was excellent. She got salmon I got short rib....chef knows how to do both fish and red meat well! Dessert and drinks were amazing...very good Manhattans. Great building great staff great location and easy to park. Very warm and inviting and charming. Will definitely return and have recommended to friends and family
While the restaurant was very nice and we enjoyed our experience the food was very different from what we expected. Maybe it was us but the food was just odd. Everything was served in a bowl and mashed together. The food was delicious but I prefer to eat my mashed potatoes without having to go thru my meat and way too much wilted spinach. My guy will eat pretty much anything and he was not impressed with how our meals were presented. The place was fairly full so this is just my opinion. If you like pretentious food then this is the place for you.
Friendly reception at front door. Very happy to see all staff wearing face coverings. Ordered cocktails- recommend the Sidney Manhattan. Pennsylvania trout with mushrooms was delicious! Short rib also yummy. Will definitely return.
Great food, ate outdoors on the Terrace, good social distancing. Very pleasant. Only issue is that there is a lot of noise from PA 234--we had a 5 pm reservation. Eating later would avoid the rush hour noise. Food is fabulous.
The Japanese peppers from their garden was a nice complement to my meal.
Amazing experience! Our waitress was awesome and the food was great... I highly recommend.
This place is a hidden gem and well worth the drive from Carlisle!!
Perfect Meal. The chef is a master at complimenting and contrasting flavors that work
The menu still is limited, or perhaps less adventurous is a better term, compared to pre-Covid. Still, it is the best restaurant in the area by far.
Lovely, quaint space with excellent food. Flavorful and creative. Good service Low noise. Higher end prices but worth it for a great dining experience.
Unique tastes and excellent service. We will go back!
Food was delicious as always. The wait staff was very accommodating. Can’t wait to go back!
Excellent meal and service. One of our favorite restaurants. Somewhat limited dinner menu, but anything we've eaten there has been outstanding.
Superior service, outstanding food! The gluten free options were phenomenal including appetizer, main dish, and dessert. We will definitely be dining at Sidney again! We had a wonderful experience!!!
Service and food was wonderful. Highly recommend!!
The food was amazing as always. Service was perfect. Couldn’t have asked for a better way to celebrate our 15th anniversary!
Food and service were excellent...Really enjoy dining at Sydney whenever we get a chance to get there!!
Sidney is our favorite restaurant and we are lucky enough to live only 25 minutes away. Excellent food always, and presentation is lovely and imaginative. Also, Sidney has a really good wines and mixed drinks. Husband said his wine was the best he’s had in years. Their staff is friendly, welcoming, and very knowledgeable. We were seated outside and had a wonderful dinner there Friday evening 8/7/2020.
Second year celebrating our anniversary here. Everything was excellent. We were greeted with a lovely champagne toast. A nice little extra. The menu was limited but still had good choices. And our marinated steaks were delicious and done perfectly.
We sat outside by the fountain with our couple friends. The wine they ordered from Portugal was a blend and top notch.
Our food was delicious and RJ’s drinks were wonderful as usual!
Always great! Interesting menu and excellent presentation. We go to Sidney often and it’s always memorable.
Very nice evening and awesome food as normal when we been to Sydney’s every time we’re a little disappointed we could not eat outside as we had planned but it was due to possible thunderstorms and we understood
We brought friends to experience Sydney for the first time, and they LOVED it, just like us!
Service was good but all our food was brought almost at once. The waitress was upset with her staff. She took our meals back to kitchen. Only problem the food was a little chilled when brought back out.
Always an excellent meal with impeccable service and great outdoor ambience.
A lovely place I have gone to for many years.
They adjusted for the current pandemic very well.
The dining experience at Sidney was top notch as usual! The meal was superb and the service excellent. The one four star was for the music being a bit too loud.
Unique and delicious food - Excellent service! Quite exceptional.
Great place. A diamond in the country. Food quality as good as the high end restaurants in big cities.
As always great meal great service even in the midst of covid19.
It was a wonderful experience it's one of our favorite restaurants for me and my wife we celebrated our 20 year anniversary they're just this week they spoiled us with a glass of champagne the moment we sat down to start the evening from there we had amazing oysters for an appetizer an amazing beautiful meals that not only tasted amazing but they looked amazing if you haven't tried it you need to go to Sidney's
We had friends visit us from Scranton area that we had met on Hilton Head Island, SC in January. We very much wanted to take them to one of our very favorite eatery. So, we took them to Sidney. They loved it? The Cod entree was delicious.
Food was original and prepared perfectly. Service was excellent. There’re are not any negatives with this place.
So glad to be back at Sidney! We dined on oysters, salad with burrata, duck breast, braised short ribs and buttershots coffee for dessert! Everything was delicious, as usual. I highly recommend the cucumber-mint martini also - very refreshing!
Nice to be seated outside. Comfortable area with nice ambience, but traffic can be a bit loud at times. Glad to see you open for business.
We were celebrating our 50th. Anniversary. We always turn to Sidney for special occasions as well as share good times with friends. We were seated outside on the patio, the weather was great. The servers and staff all wore protective mask, which gave you a sense of security with the coronavirus present in the state. My wife and I also wore mask as required. The service, staff, food, wine, and setting was perfect for this occasion. We are looking forward to our return trip with 2 close friends this coming week.
Sidney is rated 4.8 stars by 1071 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting bookings at the moment.