Best Vegan Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Excellent all around. Very knowledgeable server with great recommendations. The zucchini appetizer was delicious as were our pasta dishes and negronis.

My wife and I came to Starlite for her birthday celebration, and we had such an amazing experience! From the atmosphere to the food and cocktails, everything was wonderful—but what really made the night special was our server, Justin. Justin was absolutely awesome! He was incredibly knowledgeable and shared some of the history of the restaurant with us, which was so interesting to learn. You could genuinely tell that he loved Starlite and had a real connection to the restaurant from before the acquisition by CH. That passion really came through in the way he talked about the food and the restaurant. They also made my wife feel so special for her birthday, which I really appreciated. The cocktails were fantastic, the Caesar salad is an absolute MUST, and honestly, do yourself a favor and get all of the steak sauces—they were all so good! Such a memorable birthday dinner, and we will definitely be back. Thank you to Justin and the entire Starlite team for making our night so special!

Great service! My drink was perfect! Excellent Arancini, Burrata was delicious, meatballs and sauce were tasty! We also ordered the pappardelle pasta and it was legit authentic, Sea Bass 10 out of 10!!

The absolute best!!! I think our waiters name was Evan and he was the best!! I’ve had him a couple of times and he gives the best service!

Amazing food and wonderful service! It was a first time visit for us and we couldn’t have been happier. Comfort food elevated with unique flavors. We’ll definitely be back!