Penn Yan Restaurants
Make a free booking
Find the right table in Penn Yan
Find the right table in Penn Yan
Let OpenTable find the best spots for you.
Powered by AI
Check out diners' favourite restaurants in Penn Yan
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
Osteria Allora
$$$$•Italian•4.6(70)Allora is a new venture with an old, familiar feel. Calling back to the family Italian restaurants of our youth, our Osteria combines regional Italian cuisine with great steaks and chops. Allora's partner, Acute Farm in Hammondsport, NY will labor to provide so many of the fresh ingredients we will serve along with many other small, family farms from the Finger Lakes region. Allora has a full bar, a wine list featuring Finger Lakes and Italian selections, and local beers and ciders. Our 60-seat dining room provides our guests with a comfortable setting for all types of dining occasions from a simple pasta dinner to a multi-course extravaganza with wines and fireworks (ok, no fireworks:-)
Located alone the Outlet Trail in the downtown historical district of Penn Yan, NY, Allora has an ample parking lot as well as boat parking on the canal for our lake faring guests. A new foot bridge over the canal connects us to the Walkerbilt Park and Band Shell and additional boat parking.Main Deck
$$$$•American•3.9(570)A lakeside eatery located in the historic and scenic enclave of Penn Yan Village. Bringing contemporary farm-to-table fare to the Finger Lakes. Serving lunch, dinner, and brunch.
For the best experience, please book a single reservation for your full party size. Separate smaller reservations cannot typically be joined together upon arrival due to seating and staffing constraints; call us at 315-694-7536 if you need help arranging a larger group.
See what locals rave about in Penn Yan
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- PPeytonGoldAustin •2 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoFood was excellent, we had breakfast and dinner here multiple times during our stay. Highly recommend the avocado toast and breakfast potatoes. Good local wine selections. The most outstanding part of our visit was our waiter, Brett, who was phenomenal. His service was amazing and he even wrote us out recommendations for our visit to Niagara Falls and NYC. He truly went above and beyond, we are so grateful! The rest of the staff were great as well.More infoRose Tavern$$$$• Unspecified• Canandaigua•4.6
- KKevinUpstate New York •3 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoThe service, food, and servers were excellent. We highly recommend you go and experience the ambiance and great hospitality of the staff.More infoNolan's on Canandaigua Lake$$$$• Steak• Canandaigua•4.7
- LLindaNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 6 days agoWe had a wonderful meal last night. Although they were quite busy, the service was excellent. We started with clams oregonato, which were wonderful. My husband had the swordfish piccata, and I had the halibut, both of which were cooked just right and delicious. We didn’t want spaghetti, and were offered a salad as a substitute. That was perfect! We appreciated also being able to order a side of nicely roasted potatoes. A truly great dinner!More infoOsteria Allora$$$$• Italian• Penn Yan•4.6
- LLindaPhiladelphia County •10 reviews4.0Dined on 31 Oct 2026Main Deck is a wonderful relatively new addition to Penn Yan. The views of the lake are outstanding, service is very attentive and the menu changes seasonally with innovative dishes. We look forward to returning.More infoMain Deck$$$$• American• Penn Yan•3.9
- JJeffGoldNew York State •528 reviews4.0Dined on 16 Oct 2026Friday night dinner after the start of our annual wine weekend with friends. Nice, warm friendly service by Tiana.More infoSapalta$$$$• Farm-to-table• Dundee•3.7
Private Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Explore private diningPrivate Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in Penn Yan is The Mansion at Keuka Lake (opens in a new tab)
The restaurants with the best service in Penn Yan are Osteria Allora (opens in a new tab), The Mansion at Keuka Lake (opens in a new tab) and Main Deck (opens in a new tab)
The restaurants with the best ambience in Penn Yan are The Mansion at Keuka Lake (opens in a new tab), Osteria Allora (opens in a new tab) and Main Deck (opens in a new tab)
Explore OpenTable
- John Briggs House
- Charles Wagener House
- Milo Station
- Lake Street Plaza Shopping Centre
- Anthony Road Wine Company
- Abner Woodworth House
- James Hobart House
- Ezikial Perry House
- Best Western PLUS Vineyard Inn and Suites
- Sampson Theatre
- Arnold Potter House
- William Swarthout Farm
- Yatesville Methodist Church
- Whitaker House
- Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse
- Uriah Hanford House
- Fox Run Vineyards
- Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham - Penn Yan
- Robert Ingersoll Birthplace
- Bellona Station
- Home
- United States
- Upstate New York